forget every thread you ever read about these two...Roy v Ed Reed

[BigDFan5]

That was my point.

Sorry confused by the wording. Cause you mentioned JJ needs to get a real FS, and then talked abot a failed GM job which JJ is the named GM

 

[CATCH17]

Watkins was off to a promising start early on, as he was beaten only on one deep pass in his first three starts.

This guy didn't watch the Eagles or Giants games.

Roy got lashed on by the fans for trying to make a play but was lashed out by the message board mafia for taking a bad angle when it wasn't even his man.

Watkins killed us in that 1st Eagles game because he was in position to make plays.

 

[DragonCowboy]

Ed Reed gave up more catches than Roy

Ed Reed gave up more yards than Roy

Ed Reed had fewer pass deflections than Roy

Ed Reed had the same amount of INTs as Roy

Reed allowed 6 TDs Roy allowed 8


Now according to you the TDs make Reed a liability but he is better than Roy because of his coverage which as the stats show Roy gave up less of everything except TDs

I must admit BigDFan, you are one good arguer.

 

[BigDFan5]

I must admit BigDFan, you are one good arguer.

:laugh2: Marriage will do that to you.

 

[DragonCowboy]

:laugh2: Marriage will do that to you.

Heh I get my fair share of arguments with my parents. :laugh2:

 

[Billy Bullocks]

Ed Reed is a FREE safety and RW is a STRONG.

Ed Reed is suppose to be a ball hawk.

Why are we having this conversation?

Because you can be a homer and use this stance to justify your beliefs, or you can admit that Ed Reed is more of a difference maker than Roy Williams, period.

 

[big dog cowboy]

:laugh2: Marriage will do that to you.

Dat true.

 

[zrinkill]

Because you can be a hater and make things up about Roy with no facts

Fixed it for ya.

 

[BigDFan5]

Because you can be a homer and use this stance to justify your beliefs, or you can admit that Ed Reed is more of a difference maker than Roy Williams, period.

I havent seen anyone arguing Roy is better than Reed

 

[Cbz40]

:laugh2: Marriage will do that to you.

Who wins those BigD???? tell the truth now...:laugh2:

 

[zrinkill]

I havent seen anyone arguing Roy is better than Reed

We have said many times that Reed is a better free safety than Roy


Thats not Roy's position ..... but if it makes the Haters happy.

 

[Billy Bullocks]

Ive seen plenty of people argue different stnaces. FS vs SS, supporting cast, etc. Ill agree with most of it. But lets be real, Reed seems to show up wen it really counts. Williams played well against Seattle, but watching him and Brady James on Jerramy Stevens pretty much summed up our pass coverage this season. Both of those guys are total clowns out there.

 

[zrinkill]

I also would like to say that Ed Reed is a much better Free Safety than Ware


Ware should be ashamed .....

 

[zrinkill]

Heck ...... Reed is a better free safety than the great Lawrence Taylor ......

Why did they let that bum in the HOF .....

 

[BigDFan5]

Who wins those BigD???? tell the truth now...:laugh2:

I have never won one.

It usually ends with "yes dear, you are right"

 

[DragonCowboy]

I also would like to say that Ed Reed is a much better Free Safety than Ware


Ware should be ashamed .....

Cut that freaking underachiever!

He can't do anything!

God I hate him so much!

 

[zrinkill]

Cut that freaking underachiever!

He can't do anything!

God I hate him so much!

Ed Reed is also a better Free safety than Emmitt Smith ......

what a loser

 

[DragonCowboy]

Ed Reed is also a better Free safety than Emmitt Smith ......

what a loser

ya man, that emmitt smith guy will never amount to anything.

 

[locked&loaded]

then according to you, roy must be a HUGE, HUGE liability compared to reed.

yet he only gave up 2 int's more, fewer completions, etc.

And before you go into your "why can't you ever be wrong" tirade, remember who started this thread.

ill remember the posters taht had to make it into a flame war thats all ill remember.

 

[zrinkill]

ill remember the posters taht had to make it into a flame war thats all ill remember.

scarrryyyyyyyy