You're right about FA and FF changing things. FF has been a two-edged sword. On one hand it brought in more fans in general, but on the other hand it watered down the team-centric fandom and led to more individual player fandom over teams. FA also has/had its good and bad. Several things have changed the game over the years. Is it better, worse, or both but just different?
Free agency and the salary cap imposed in the post 1994 Collective Bargaining Agreement era between the owners and players union created enforced parity. The New England Patriots have been the best example of a franchise that capitalized on it via a:
- 100% supportive, removed from practically all football management affairs owner
- Super Bowl caliber defensive minded head coach
- superb quarterback, whose career established him as the best ever
- virtually annual mix of solid defensive units balanced with offensive squads that executed extremely well
Both time and variables (notably Tom Brady) removed from the competitive formula combined to disrupt it but it lasted for decades. New England exploited the current era's setup much more than all other franchises.
Is the game better for the owners and players union? Yes. Is the overall game better by eliminating multiple dominating franchises per era through greater distribution of player talent leaguewide? No.
The exchange, for making practically every team every year to be 'good enough' and birth competitiveness for most games, created a void devoid of truly superior teams that reigned for
YEARS. Packers. Dolphins. Steelers. Cowboys. Franchises like these did not go undefeated every season. Even Miami was an outlier. However, there were many games when lessor opponents PLAYED UP TO the level of the best in football. Many that could be described as knockdown, dragged out fights. The best of the best usually won but there were more memorable instances when underdogs won.
That quality of overall NFL football gradually eroded season after season after the ratification of that fateful CBA to what we have today. Professional football is still exciting to watch. Elements like modern fantasy football injects an artificial sense of adrenalin. So has legalized sports betting.
Parity lies beneath it all now. Championship favorites now are a year-to-year manifestation of hitting on
just the right draft choices with immediate gameday impact, identifying
just the right holes to fill in free agency, having
just enough on-the-same-page communication between coaches and players and maintaining
just the right degree of health of the handful of core top players.
Now, the best of the best one year can get one or more of those wrong and they can be easily out of the playoffs or even end up with losing records the very next year. That is a commonplace occurrence now. It is what younger fans have mostly or entirely experienced for their whole fanship with the NFL.
This is the new norm but it is not what it used to be. My one hope as an old fan is that the National Football League does not 'evolve' into something better than it is now.
Flag football anyone..?
/rant