CATCH17
1st Round Pick
- Messages
- 67,075
- Reaction score
- 84,672
Alex Smith is much better.
Ok but he’s also been in the league forever.
Daks best football looked a lot better then Smiths imo.
Last edited:
Alex Smith is much better.
Getting sick of all the Dak threads.
McNair always put up numbers like 15-27 for a 170 yards and like 30-40 yards rushing. He had a prime Eddie George and Jamal Lewis with high quality olines with players such as Bruce Matthews, Joanthen Odgen etc. Similarly, to us with Zeke and our oline. The most tds McNair ever had in a season was 24. I think this is the best comparison you can make for Dak. He's not Mcnabb. He's not Russel Wilson. Etc. Opinions
do not agree alex was great last year and he was great in San Fran Dak will hope to have career like Smiths..at the rate hes missing open TE/WRs he wont be around long..Alex smith was drivng a Grey Hound bus and Daks on the short bus right now..Dak is struggling to just hit the guys in the flats, hot check downs etc..he better get it togetherOk but he’s also been in the league forever.
Daks best football looked a lot better then Smiths imo.
Smith is more accurate but he is a very good runner.
Oh damn your right...What kind of offense do you think we're running?
It's a back when offense.
do not agree alex was great last year and he was great in San Fran Dak will hope to have career like Smiths..at the rate hes missing open TE/WRs he wont be around long..Alex smith was drivng a Grey Hound bus and Daks on the short bus right now..Dak is struggling to just hit the guys in the flats, hot check downs etc..he better get it together
Daks gonna need a great supporting cast if he wants to win that championship. These guys he’s getting compared to haven’t been able to do it.
LOLI can't take it anymore.
Ok but he’s also been in the league forever.
Daks best football looked a lot better then Smiths imo.
McNair's TD-to-INT ratio and passer rating and completion percentages say otherwise, in general.McNair was a much better passer, IMO.
McNabb was a better passer, had some early mechanics issues but Reid and his staff worked it out.Still think McNabb is the closest. McNabb was a bit better athlete IMO and I believe faster. Probably a bit stronger arm. Dak is a more natural leader while McNabb was a bit of knucklehead.