The decision comes down to whether you think Pollard at 10-ish million a year and a rookie on a rookie deal can approximate what you get from Pollard and Zeke on a combined salary of 15-16 million. OR do you think Zeke for 6-7 million and rookie on rookie deal can outperform Zeke and Pollard? I am of the mind that the change of pace splash play guy is easier to replace than the meat and potatoes guy. I recognize that other see it differently. What Pollard accomplished against bottom feeder defenses while Zeke was out was nice but Zeke has feasted on bottom feeder defenses at an even higher level when he was allowed to. Those games are nice.. but averaging just barely 2 ypc against good defensive fronts cannot be ignored.
Would you rather have the guy who can get you 120 yards a game against chumps but barely 20 a game against tougher fronts or the guy who might only get you 90-100 against chumps but will deliver 70-80 against the tougher defenses as well. The answer to me comes down to which level of defense do you think you are likely to see in the playoffs. People are free to feel however they want about it. There's only three people whose feelings about it actually matter. And none of those three is on this board.
Zeke is just a short yardage and goal line back at best.
He's been a washed up starter between the 10 yard lines for 2+years because he's too slooowwww bruh!
He was a progress stopper for Pollard for over 2 years and now he's just a progress stopper for the other younger rbs like Davis rn.
Let's see what Pollard and Davis can do behind this oline and use Zeke down by the end zone.
Both of those guys are wayyyyy better than Zeke is rn as runners.
Pollard and Davis are a better tandem between the 10 yard lines. Imo
Zeke and his 35 yard playoff rushing yards is why we lost. Defenses don't fear him like they do Pollard
He's just spelling all of the Pro Bowl rbs involvement at this point
I wouldnt use Zeke for more than 6-7 carries per game. He's a 3rd RB at best.
If I was Pollard I'd say heck no I want 3/4 of the carries.
Just do what Witten did and don't come off the field TP
Pollard is the pro bowler so go sit you slow molasses self down.