I’ve said this before and I’ll say it again. I don’t want to be a conspiracy theorist but they make it really hard. I want to believe the discrepancies in calls are due to human error, but they’re making it really hard.
I can’t remember who posted it and what thread but someone post all the teams since 2000 to have 100+ penalties a year. During those 22 years we had 18 seasons of 100+ penalties.
Very difficult for me to believe we would have penalty problems between 5 head coaches, Campo, Parcells, Phillips, Garrett and now McCarthy. Someone pulled up the data. The data is pretty alarming. IMO a little too alarming for human error.
But to answer your main question. It’s a better story that Dallas retires an aging Tom Brady and then faces their next big bully in the 49ers, which rekindles a long storied rivalry . Good for ratings. Why they don’t rig it so we’re in the Super Bowl? They don’t have to. They make plenty of money without Dallas being involved.
I dug those numbers up, and they also confirm darling team status for both Pittsburgh and Green bay - two teams who a lot of people think get ref calls their way most of the time - and that perception is correct.
The numbers confirm that Dallas is a ref dog and GB and Pittsburgh are ref darlings.
We had 18 of 23 season from 2000-2022 with 100+ penalties (last in the NFL) and ZERO seasons with 80 or less (again, last in the NFL).
Green Bay? Only 11 seasons with 100+ and 4 seasons with 80 or less.
Pittsburgh? Only 10 seasons with 100+ and 3 seasons with 80 or less.
People who try to say their is no conspiracy will claim that the calls even out in the long run. They sure do for ref darlings like Pittsburgh and Green Bay who's numbers are close to each other, but then we get to Dallas and we have numbers that are far too out of the median to be human error, and we have far too large of a sample size with well over 300 games and 2 decades.
Also, this does not take into account the no calls which are just as effective in screwing Dallas as the bad calls.
Then, take into account the history of all time bad calls that have cost Dallas the Ice Bowl, Super Bowl 5, Super Bowl 10, the 1994 NFCCG, and the Dez double standard game (Dez didn't "catch it" while Cobb "did" - both calls were wrong). Dallas should probably have 4 more SB titles to it's name.