NFL Poll : Who is the best pass rusher in the league?

adamknite

adamknite

Well-Known Member
Messages
4,226
Reaction score
805
DaBoys4Life;2459351 said:
Yeah....Woodley




Obviously we have different books....:D
Click to expand...

Hos's book


51ASBE5X70L.jpg



:p:
 
Hostile

Hostile

The Duke
Messages
119,565
Reaction score
4,544
adamknite;2459352 said:
Hos's book


51ASBE5X70L.jpg



:p:
Click to expand...
Man, if I need that book I'm in serious trouble. I spent a lot of money on a degree in English.
 
TheCount

TheCount

Pixel Pusher
Messages
25,523
Reaction score
8,849
DaBoys4Life;2459351 said:
Yeah....Woodley




Obviously we have different books....:D
Click to expand...

Woodley's a fine rusher, but he's not as disruptive as Harrison. What really amazes me is that Harrison went undrafted, spent years on the practice squad, then ran mostly special teams, never really getting a shot to be a focus until when they got rid of Joey Porter.

I mean that's a pretty darn good way to get to where he is, you can't hate on that.

We spent a very high pick on Ware, we expected a lot from him and he hasn't disappointed. But to go from undrafted to potential MVP, like Romo, is pretty special.
 
adamknite

adamknite

Well-Known Member
Messages
4,226
Reaction score
805
Hostile;2459355 said:
Man, if I need that book I'm in serious trouble. I spent a lot of money on a degree in English.
Click to expand...


That's the beauty of the joke. ;)
 

DaBoys4Life

Benched
Messages
15,626
Reaction score
0
TheCount;2459361 said:
Woodley's a fine rusher, but he's not as disruptive as Harrison. What really amazes me is that Harrison went undrafted, spent years on the practice squad, then ran mostly special teams, never really getting a shot to be a focus until when they got rid of Joey Porter.

I mean that's a pretty darn good way to get to where he is, you can't hate on that.

We spent a very high pick on Ware, we expected a lot from him and he hasn't disappointed. But to go from undrafted to potential MVP, like Romo, is pretty special.
Click to expand...

ah I see....Ware still better and I'd still rather have Ware than him.
 
jobberone

jobberone

Kane Ala
Messages
54,219
Reaction score
19,659
Hostile;2457173 said:
Reggie is the best I ever saw and I've seen Harvey, Deacon, and Bruce as well. No one combined his pure power with his kind of speed and size.

I will say this though. None of them could have played OLB in a 3-4 and covered receivers.
Click to expand...

Deacon Jones was the best IMO although he wasn't as strong as Reggie. Deacon Jones was a dirty player. They finally had to stop the head slap as no one could handle him. He's one of the truly mean guys I've ever seen on a field of play. I'm sure there were arguably meaner and dirtier but he is in the top Ten at least.

He and Merlin Olsen were almost unstoppable. But he didn't beat up on on one Cowboy.
 
Hostile

Hostile

The Duke
Messages
119,565
Reaction score
4,544
jobberone;2459372 said:
Deacon Jones was the best IMO although he wasn't as strong as Reggie. Deacon Jones was a dirty player. They finally had to stop the head slap as no one could handle him. He's one of the truly mean guys I've ever seen on a field of play. I'm sure there were arguably meaner and dirtier but he is in the top Ten at least.

He and Merlin Olsen were almost unstoppable. But he didn't beat up on on one Cowboy.
Click to expand...
Tell me this.

Deacon and Reggie, no head slap allowed. Who would you take?

Deacon and Reggie, allowing the head slap. Who would you take?

My answer is Reggie both times.

Deacon was owned by Rayfield Wright. Reggie by Big E.
 

dallasfaniac

Active Member
Messages
4,198
Reaction score
1
Harrison's QB sack and pressures have come at the expense of the most sacked QBs in the NFL. He has multiple sack games against these type of QBs and big fat zeros against other QBs.

Ware puts up multiple sack games when facing these QBs too, but brings pressure consistently no matter which QB he faces.
 
TheCount

TheCount

Pixel Pusher
Messages
25,523
Reaction score
8,849
DaBoys4Life;2459366 said:
ah I see....Ware still better and I'd still rather have Ware than him.
Click to expand...

I never said he was better than Ware.
 

SteelManiac55

New Member
Messages
92
Reaction score
0
03EBZ06;2459744 said:
I could be wrong but I pretty sure DWare has two PDs but Kirwan gives no credit to Dware.
Click to expand...

NFL.com does not credit Ware with a PD this season. I'm sure, considering his place of employment, that was his source of information.
 
masomenos

masomenos

Less is more
Messages
5,983
Reaction score
33
Kirwan's formula, much like his Strength and Speed Scores in the draft, is a good idea but it just doesn't make a lot of sense in the way it's calculated.

How are sacks, knockdowns and hurries all equal in value? Since they all have different impacts in a game they should also impact the formula differently. Sacks should be weighted the heaviest, then knockdowns (which are basically just really good hurries), and then hurries.

Taking total tackles is also misleading. The stats should be split up into solo tackles and assists with solos being weighted higher.There should also be an inclusion for TFL

I struggle with the idea of awarding any points for safeties simply because they're just sacks that have a different impact because of where they occur on the field. If you award points for safeties then shouldn't you award points for hurries/knockdowns that lead to INTs? Shouldn't you award points for FFs that are returned for TDs by teammates? Shouldn't you award more points for a crucial sack than a garbage time sack?
 
masomenos

masomenos

Less is more
Messages
5,983
Reaction score
33
I just created a formula that is more in line with how I think the stats should be weighted. I only compared Woodley, Harrison and Ware but the results were...

Ware: 54.13
Woodley: 51.75
Harrison: 49.13
 

SteelManiac55

New Member
Messages
92
Reaction score
0
How is Harrison possibly last amongst the three of them? What factors of his game actually lost him points?
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top