Rank the Cowboys WR Corp Against Playoff Teams

[cnuball21]

Deebo and CeeDee about a wash. Gallup better than Aiyuck

Fair on CeeDee / Deebo…but think you need to go check out what Aiyuk has done on a per game basis vs what MG has done.

 

[DTK]

Last season’s conference championships featured Chase, Deebo, Kupp, OBJ, Higgins, Tyreek and Kelce.
Based on that I’m going to say WR play may be one of the most important indicators of a team’s success.

True, a lot of good WR's you named there. I just don't think WR play is as important as other things, like QB & line play. But that's what makes football the best sport, takes a whole team to win a title.

 

[cnuball21]

Last season’s conference championships featured Chase, Deebo, Kupp, OBJ, Higgins, Tyreek and Kelce.
Based on that I’m going to say WR play may be one of the most important indicators of a team’s success.

I think it’s underrated…like Dan said earlier I don’t think we need to change our identity by any means. Let’s try to pound the rock, get CeeDee in motion a lot and do our PA to our TEs.

That being said - if I’m playing the Cowboys I’m going to stack the box and give Lamb all the attention and make WRs 2 or 3 beat me.

 

[aikemirv]

Would not disagree with that. I went to the Giants game and Dallas ran majority 2 and 3 TE sets, they still threw the ball out of that formation

We are very successful throwing out of that formation!

Honestly Moore just can't put it all together! We do one thing solid one game or drive, then go away from it completely for games and then come back to it. He is hard to figure!

 

[CowboysExchange]

probably the 9ers honestly

Wait until the 49ers have Deebo and Mccaffery coming out as the 1-2 punch in the playoffs

Garropulo is very replaceable imo but the addition of Mccaffery makes them more solid than last year imo

 

[Proof]

Wait until the 49ers have Deebo and Mccaffery coming out as the 1-2 punch in the playoffs

Garropulo is very replaceable imo but the addition of Mccaffery makes them more solid than last year imo

yeah, deebo and aiyuk, c-mac and elijah mitchell, kittle... their dangerous.

 

[Doomsday101]

We are very successful throwing out of that formation!

Honestly Moore just can't put it all together! We do one thing solid one game or drive, then go away from it completely for games and then come back to it. He is hard to figure!

I'm sorry I don't have the same dislike of Moore, as others do. He has had to deal with starting QB going down and yet this team is still showing a lot of success. Offense has increased in production. I see balance in the offense , not strictly running it or strictly passing it. Does this mean I agree with every single play he calls? no but by and large he has been getting it done. As many people who come down on Dak and yet this offense is producing it is amazing how little credit Moore gets from them

 

[StarOfGlory]

WR corp? I think we are right in the middle.
Teams I see higher than us: Mia, Buff, Cincy, Minn, TB, Sea
Teams I see us better than: Jets, Bal, Tenn, KC, NYG, SF
Eagles about a push

Who is the other team in the playoffs right now? Chargers?

Eagles a push at WR? I may be a homer but I'm not blind.

Even if you want to call Brown and CD equal--which they are not this year, you are saying that Gallup is better than Davonte Smith, and that Schultz is better than Goedart. Do we have a #3 as good as Watkins? And those Eagle receivers are getting it done with Hurts throwing to them. Dak is a better passer than Hurts.

 

[cnuball21]

Eagles a push at WR? I may be a homer but I'm not blind.

Even if you want to call Brown and CD equal--which they are not this year, you are saying that Gallup is better than Davonte Smith, and that Schultz is better than Goedart. Do we have a #3 as good as Watkins? And those Eagle receivers are getting it done with Hurts throwing to them. Dak is a better passer than Hurts.

Yea Philly is miles ahead of us. They’re near the top of the list IMO.

 

[CowboysExchange]

I'm sorry I don't have the same dislike of Moore, as others do. He has had to deal with starting QB going down and yet this team is still showing a lot of success. Offense has increased in production. I see balance in the offense , not strictly running it or strictly passing it. Does this mean I agree with every single play he calls? no but by and large he has been getting it done. As many people who come down on Dak and yet this offense is producing it is amazing how little credit Moore gets from them

Give Moore credit for his knowledge and success within our division.

But outside our division and againt playoff contention he still gets a low grade imo

Anybody scheming our offense around a bunch of take what the defense gives ya tes isn't gonna get high grades from me. Js

None of these tes are good at anything besides blocking (esp getting separation on intermediate passes and in the red zone) so it's just 1-2 less scoring threats on the field on every passing snap.

 

[Doomsday101]

Give Moore credit for his knowledge and success within our division.

But outside our division and againt playoff contention he still gets a low grade imo

that is your opinion. This season Dallas beaten Minn, we have beaten Cinn both playoff contenders

 

[ChuckA1]

I'd say the Cowboys are at least top-3 in the NFC.

 

[Jarntt]

Fair on CeeDee / Deebo…but think you need to go check out what Aiyuk has done on a per game basis vs what MG has done.

Gallup is just more talented IMO. He has been hurt and Dak often doesn't look his way so he doesn't get as many targets as he otherwise might. But if you are going to play that card, you need to be consistent.
CeeDee 12 games: 69 receptions; 928 yards; 6 TDs
Deebo: 11 games: 50 receptions; 569 yards; 2 TDs

So if you are basing your opinion on who is better on per game stats for Gallup and Aiyuck then you need to do the same with CeeDee vs Deebo

 

[ESisback]

We need to rank the QBs decision making among the teams

Thanks Coogs! I thought for 17 erroneous seconds we could enjoy ONE thread without QB1 drama!

 

[CowboysExchange]

that is your opinion. This season Dallas beaten Minn, we have beaten Cinn both playoff contenders

Minnesota and the Cowboys are the 2 most overhyped playoff contenders

Neither will advance that far in the playoffs because their pedigree is ONLY ON TURF

The Cowboys matched up good against Cincinnati when we played them. But they weren't very consistent then either

 

[Jarntt]

Eagles a push at WR? I may be a homer but I'm not blind.

Even if you want to call Brown and CD equal--which they are not this year, you are saying that Gallup is better than Davonte Smith, and that Schultz is better than Goedart. Do we have a #3 as good as Watkins? And those Eagle receivers are getting it done with Hurts throwing to them. Dak is a better passer than Hurts.

Why are you using TE? The thread say WR corp, not overall receiving corp.

IMO CeeDee and Gallup are as I put it "about a push" with their top 2. Gallup is just now getting healthy and we played with a backup QB for half the year so you can't just pull stats. Not sure why you are saying that I said Gallup is better than Smith and Schultz is better than Goedert. I didn't say that. Also, Brown has played as well as Watkins.

 

[Doomsday101]

Minnesota and the Cowboys are the 2 most overhyped playoff contenders

Neither will advance that far in the playoffs because their pedigree is ONLY ON TURF

fine but you claimed they have not beat contenders, fact is no matter how you feel about Minn they are 10-2 on the season and they have beaten some top teams like Buffalo as soon as Dallas win now Minn is overrated. lol

 

[Ken]

We need to rank the QBs decision making among the teams

I know it is hard for you, but try and stay on topic. If you want to talk about the same inaccurate thing for the 1000th time, start a new thread.

 

[CowboysExchange]

fine but you claimed they have not beat contenders, fact is no matter how you feel about Minn they are 10-2 on the season and they have beaten some top teams like Buffalo as soon as Dallas win now Minn is overrated. lol

Minnesota has been overrated for longer than the Cowboys

Its nothing new.

Regular season mahomes is not as good as playoff mahomes is more of where I'm going w this

If we're playing on turf throughout the playoffs I'd say we had a better shot.

If we draw Philly or Sf we're One and Done imo simply because we don't have a playoff level grass pedigree and they have better overall teams

Minnesota has cousins and come playoff time he'll just be the avg up and down QB that he always has been

Just like Tannehill

Dak was used to having a better receiving core. The only reason our offense is somewhat competitive this year is because Pollard is being used as a main threat this year imo

 

[cnuball21]

Gallup is just more talented IMO. He has been hurt and Dak often doesn't look his way so he doesn't get as many targets as he otherwise might. But if you are going to play that card, you need to be consistent.
CeeDee 12 games: 69 receptions; 928 yards; 6 TDs
Deebo: 11 games: 50 receptions; 569 yards; 2 TDs

So if you are basing your opinion on who is better on per game stats for Gallup and Aiyuck then you need to do the same with CeeDee vs Deebo

Gallup was more talented before injury…100%. Because he got hurt and hasn’t looked the same doesn’t change anything about right now and our outlook for the playoffs.

What does Lamb / Deebo have to do with anything? I already agreed with you on that.