Again just because they call themselves something does not mean the jobs fit your preconceived notion of who does what.
Okay.
you have shown no real proof for yours
I asked for one instance of Jerry not letting coaches coach their scheme.
Our GM stands alone as the only NFL GM that never watches game film. He can't be bothered with making the roster better when he's busy booking the next Monster Truck event at the stadium.
Lurie is very involved, as much as any owner. He is not involved in evaluating player talent. Roseman is, but is not particularly good at it. He is not good at day one drafts, lots of misses. Lurie only purchased the Eagles because he failed in his bid to buy his beloved Patriots. He trusts Roseman and they collaborate well enough. Lurie participates in all pertinent decisions. If that’s meddling then he is meddlesome.
Neither can you. But Jerry makes himself GM and usurps power from the head coach, even if its only perceived.
It's a quarter to 5 Saturday afternoon CDT (6 EDT)...I suppose the thread still being on page one is the number of responses on how ludicrous the OP presented this thread.
That is what I am saying. Call McClay the GM and it is essentially the same thing. We are a bit different as Lurie will tell his coaches what to call while we have extra voices like Stephen.
You can keep repeating assertions if it makes you feel better.
Im not sure about that, neither of us can say with 100% confidence that Jerry doesn't say who he wants playing....BUT we can absolutey say with 100% facts he has gone and made trades the coach didnt want...true? HOF coach with skins on the wall got a player he didnt want..thats a fact.
So? The committee is not always a consensus. Who cares?
Once the staff is set, he let's the coaches coach. Gailey, Campo, Parcells, Phillips, Marinelli, Garrett, and now MM have all been allowed to implement their schemes and the organization shifts its personnel strategy accordingly.
you should rewrite this and leave out the nba references.
Lurie does not “tell his coaches what to call”. The difference in the two teams’ front office hierarchies is Roseman can be fired. Stephen really cannot. The Roseman is a genius nonsense is one of those fantasies fanbases come up with. He once insisted on drafting Lane Johnson overruling Chip Kelly who wanted to draft someone else. Probably says more about Chip Kelly than Roseman. I think the Cowboys would be well served hiring a GM and giving him the last word on player personnel.
“You just go over what are some of the strengths and weaknesses of the opponent, that’s about it,” Lurie said. “You’re not going over detailed game plans. That would be a waste of their time with me. It’s more like, ‘I think we can attack this player. This is a mismatch I want to go after. This defensive coordinator is new at that team.’ We look at film from X, Y and Z, try to evaluate him, see how it applies to the personnel they have, for example like this week on the Commanders. It’s really kind of good stuff but it’s not meant to take up a lot of time.”
Bull ....... only one was Parcells ...... and even he got TO pushed on him.
No one is arguing he doesn't make personnel decisions. He did not tell Parcells how to coach him or how to scheme him.
I never claimed he did ...... I said he interferes with them having authority over the players and demands certain players be played.
