No more reclamation projects at the QB position.
No more attempting to try to out-smart the rest of league.
No more clinging on to the present false optimism of the complete recovery, and return to glory of the current QB.
Few examples:
1. New York Giants were a Super Bowl team in 2000, made the playoffs again in 2002, then decided in 2004, drafted Eli Manning in the 1st round.
2. Pittsburgh Steelers played in AFC championship game in 2002, won a playoff game in 2003, then also in 2004, drafted Ben Roethlisberger in the 1st round.
3. Green Bay Packers were a consistent playoff team through the 2002-2004 season, then had the foresight to draft Aaron Rogers in the 1st round in 2005.
Point being, even playoff teams and competent front offices draft QB's in the 1st round, if the value is there.
Don't get cute & don't talk yourself out of drafting a QB
The time is now to draft the QB for the present and build for the future.
Good post. Just a few things I would add.
The Giants didn't draft Manning. San Diego drafted Eli Manning at #1 and traded him to New York for their #4 overall pick, Philip Rivers.
The Packers have agressively selected quarterbacks in various rounds since the days of Ron Wolf, drafting college quarterbacks like Mark Brunell (5th round), Matt Hasselbeck (6th round) or even Matt Flynn (7th round). I would say the Pack's quarterback evaluation is very good but it's also important knowing Rodgers, who graded as highly as Alex Smith, fell into Green Bay's laps at their 24th overall selection.
Roethlisberger was the best example of the three of a value pick at quarterback. The Steelers squatted at number 11 and got their targeted man outside the top ten, something even the Packers with Rodgers couldn't claim since their man was projected as high as the #1 overall selection.
My concerns for Dallas centers on whether our current staff can accurately evaluate potentially great quarterback talent--and not simply run with assumed talent projections. If we're sitting at #4 and don't plan to trade down, I hope the pick is solid if it's quarterback because you as a franchise can't flub a high first round pick at the position.
This year's high first round quarterback prospects must have the "obvious" potential of a Manning, Roethlisberger or Rodgers. They cannot be overvalued and turn out to be another Tim Couch, Akili Smith, Chad McNown or even Daunte Culpepper--all top 15 overall selections picked in the infamous 1999 draft. Are any of the current top QB prospects as good as the one quarterback, Donovan McNabb, from that particular first round draft class who played well enough during his career to justify high first rounder? That's my main concern. I would hate if lower projected round but higher potential QB talent was discarded for another player who can't excel in the pros. If there is an Aikman waiting at #4 fine but there will be loads of regrets down the road if there's a Ryan Leaf hiding in plain sight.