Saints to release FS Dwight Smith

[Bob Sacamano]

14 picks in 4 years is what he's good for.

Go to NFL.com and find 5 NFL free safeties who have better INT totals in the last 4 years. Good luck, and pack a sandwich.

he has as many picks as Roy WIlliams

 

[Stash]

he has as many picks as Roy WIlliams in the past 2 years

Wow, keep laughin' all of us are.

Guess using your "logic", we should dump Roy too?

Keep diggin' the hole on this one....

 

[InmanRoshi]

he has as many picks as Roy WIlliams in the past 2 years

Again, 14 INT's in 4 years. I just need a list of five.

If he's as mediocre as you think it should take you no time at all.

Its NFL.com. Again .... NFL.com. Go to the Stats tab.

 

[wileedog]

half of them came in those 1st 2 years, he had 2 INTs and 5 pass-breakups last year, yeah, we really need him and in turn need to fuss if we dont' sign hm

With one of the league's worst pass rushes.

The majority of his picks came playing on a decent defense in Tampa.

Do the math.

 

[Bob Sacamano]

And 2 INTs and 5 PDs is better than Davis, no?

yes, but damn, that was Dwight's 5th year

I see a pattern though

'03-5 picks
'04-3 picks
'05-2 picks

I see this guy getting worse

 

[Stash]

yes, but damn, that was Dwight's 5th year

I see a pattern though

'03-5 picks
'04-3 picks
'05-2 picks

I see this guy getting worse

Yeah, it's all downhill at 27.

Keep diggin'!

:shootfoot

 

[Bob Sacamano]

Wow, keep laughin' all of us are.

Guess using your "logic", we should dump Roy too?

Keep diggin' the hole on this one....

I'll still be laughing when we don't sign him and when you guys start whining :laugh1:

 

[Bob Sacamano]

Again, 14 INT's in 4 years. I just need a list of five.

If he's as mediocre as you think it should take you no time at all.

sorry, what have you done for me lately, I'll find 10 safeties who had more INTs than he did last year for you

Its NFL.com. Again .... NFL.com. Go to the Stats tab.

hommedic

 

[Bob Sacamano]

With one of the league's worst pass rushes.

The majority of his picks came playing on a decent defense in Tampa.

Do the math.

ok, I did the math, and see someone who's been average the past 2 seasons, and just got cut

 

[Stash]

I'll still be laughing when we don't sign him and when you guys start whining :laugh1:

That's your stance now?

Give up the fight and pray they don't sign him?

ray2:

Good move, you were getting murdered with facts......

:abuseme:

 

[superpunk]

yes, but damn, that was Dwight's 5th year

I see a pattern though

'03-5 picks
'04-3 picks
'05-2 picks

I see this guy getting worse

He was playing SS last year.


Do you see the same thing for Roy?

 

[Bob Sacamano]

He was playing SS last year.

cuz he got beat out by a 2nd year player at FS, his supposed, "best position"

Do you see the same thing for Roy?

I see someone who is average in coverage, just like Dwight

 

[superpunk]

sorry, what have you done for me lately, I'll find 10 safeties who had more INTs than he did last year for you

You can say the exact same thing for Roy. Was he the 10th best safety in the league last year?

 

[InmanRoshi]

sorry, what have you done for me lately, I'll find 10 safeties who had more INTs than he did last year for you

That's not what I asked for . All I asked for is 5 NFL free safeties who have better than 14 INT's in the last 4 years. That's all I asked for. Can you do it? Yes or no? Its very simple.

If you attempt to change the subject one more time, I'm going to assume no and you're just admitting defeat.

 

[Bob Sacamano]

You can say the exact same thing for Roy. Was he the 10th best safety in the league last year?

he rated a 97 last year, so no

 

[Stash]

cuz he got beat out by a 2nd year player at FS, his supposed, "best position"




I see someone who is average in coverage, just like Dwight

And what would Keith Davis be in coverage?

 

[Bob Sacamano]

That's not what I asked for . All I asked for is 5 NFL free safeties who have better than 14 INT's in the last 4 years. That's all I asked for. Can you do it? Yes or no? Its very simple.

nope, I cant, and frankly, it doesn't matter what he has done in his career, lately he sucks

 

[superpunk]

cuz he got beat out by a 2nd year player at FS, his supposed, "best position"

I see someone who is average in coverage, just like Dwight

And I see a guy who, when he played for a good defense, was actually quite a player - certainly MUCH better than anyone currently on the roster.

Noone is saying Dwight is some god, and we'll die if we don't sign him. But he's certainly a better option than anything else we have.

 

[Bob Sacamano]

And what would Keith Davis be in coverage?

very, below average, at most

 

[Stash]

nope, I cant, and frankly, it doesn't matter what he has done in his career, lately he sucks

Again, don't let facts get in the way of a good argument.....