CZ POLL Should Jason Garrett be fired?

[Trouty]

I agree for the most part Trouty, if JJ didn't let the entire secondary walk, Lee wasn't injured, Zeke wasn't suspended, Smith wasn't out for so long, Dak falling off, now Martin with the concussion and no serviceable back ups at line backer or OL I just don't agree with it after what he did last year. I agree a team shouldn't fall apart after a few i injuries but when they're all pro bowlers and there is NO DEPTH which is due to Jerry then I can't agree with firing the HC right after a 13-3 season.

Can we agree to disagree? I really don't have anything else to add that I haven't already said so I'll leave it at that.

We certainly can agree to disagree, friend!

It seems you're at now with Garrett, where I was last year (my recollections and opinion of the 2015 season, in lieu of a great, then, 2016 season).

 

[TimHortons]

maybe we need a poll, should Jerry be removed as the GM too

That's the only poll that would be more lopsided than this one. And it's the only thing less likely than Garret getting fired

 

[MileyDancer]

Forget the last three games for a moment. What does his body of work suggest?

Mediocre **

 

[cowboyblue22]

I agree he should be fired but he wont unless the blowouts continue then it will be a different story I just wonder how jerry is going to sell this to the fans next year and all the season ticket holders how is he going to sell him as a positive if they keep losing games

 

[birdwells1]

I'm not going to bash a brand new head coach for being 8-8 his first season or two. He took over a Wade Phillips team that was 1-7 at the time and at least went 5-3.

Wasn't 2012 the year Romo was sacked for his career high of ~35 sacks? What does that say about the O line? Murray also was hurt and IIRC Felix Jones was the awesome replacement and combined they had one of the worst rushing seasons ever. Sean Lee once again hurt. Josh Brent was already starting as a back up when he killed his teammate during the season. The list goes on and on. I'm surprised we actually went 8-8 honestly but hey it's all JG's fault and has nothing to do with Jerry and his stupidity when it comes to being a GM and hence therefore an owner.

Look, I agree that JJ is the main problem but like someone posted on here "you can have a great GM and a average coach and be successful or a great coach and a average GM but with JJ being a below average GM you need one of the greatest as a coach". Imo Garrett is no where near that, he may be a better coach with a better organization but here he'll never be successful, this job is way over his head. You have to ask youself "what does he bring to the table, what advantage does he give us on the sidelines"?

We need someone that can allow this team to win more than one way, our formula of establishing the running game, wearing the other team's defense down, while keeping our defense off the field works.......until it doesn't. The thing I like a bout the Patriots is that their SYSTEM allows for them to attack you differently every week, you want to take Gronk out the game? Then they'llto Edleman, Hogan, Cooks. You want to drop seven and play coverage then they'll run for 150+ yards with Burkhead,Lewis and others. We try to win with man defeating man but don't give ourself a "technological (my term) advantage" of scheme to go with that. We have to get out of the 90s mindset because that was before free agency, we need to run more crossing routes and pick routes I said pick routes just force them to call them. Garrett was hired as a up and coming offensive genius but that hasn't materialized not only is he not a genius he doesn't even call his own plays. Sad

 

[LittleBoyBlue]

I surrender. I've been saying give him a chance, but the lack of coaching adjustments are the final straw for me. Also, Garrett is too stoic when the officials make horrible calls against us. The squeaky wheel gets the oil or however the saying goes. I no longer believe in Garrett and it's scary because he might not be going anywhere. In addition, we don't know who would be chosen to replace him. Careful what we wish for.

Yeah, I was all for Garrett... but he quickly showed he cannot coach. He hasn’t really improved. Not enough to justify him staying.

I want fresh start. Yeah, it sucks when incoming is unknown.... but... THIS THING aint going nowhere.

Like Cash said to Tango....


This whole thing... really ***** n sucks!

 

[aria]

We certainly can agree to disagree, friend!

It seems you're at now with Garrett, where I was last year (my recollections and opinion of the 2015 season, in lieu of a great, then, 2016 season).

Come back to this next year and I very well may agree, I'm just a year behind!

 

[BHendri5]

Hell no!!! why would they so something stupid like that, do not listen to the idiot fans Jerry

 

[aria]

Look, I agree that JJ is the main problem but like someone posted on here "you can have a great GM and a average coach and be successful or a great coach and a average GM but with JJ being a below average GM you need one of the greatest as a coach". Imo Garrett is no where near that, he may be a better coach with a better organization but here he'll never be successful, this job is way over his head. You have to ask youself "what does he bring to the table, what advantage does he give us on the sidelines"?

We need someone that can allow this team to win more than one way, our formula of establishing the running game, wearing the other team's defense down, while keeping our defense off the field works.......until it doesn't. The thing I like a bout the Patriots is that their SYSTEM allows for them to attack you differently every week, you want to take Gronk out the game? Then they'llto Edleman, Hogan, Cooks. You want to drop seven and play coverage then they'll run for 150+ yards with Burkhead,Lewis and others. We try to win with man defeating man but don't give ourself a "technological (my term) advantage" of scheme to go with that. We have to get out of the 90s mindset because that was before free agency, we need to run more crossing routes and pick routes I said pick routes just force them to call them. Garrett was hired as a up and coming offensive genius but that hasn't materialized not only is he not a genius he doesn't even call his own plays. Sad

Garrett is no Belichik and really no coaches are. We also don't have the GOAT QB on our team. Part of the reason NE is so successful is not only BB and Brady but the owner (hate him or not) let's his coach be a coach and GM be a GM. That will never happen here. For the record I like Dak and think hepbe fine, although I am getting a little more nervous, but he wouldn't be able to succeed in that system. Maybe some day but not at this current time.

When Romo was here he made mistakes, a lot of crucial mistakes. Yeah, he won us several games but he also lost us several games. So many people used to bash him but now once he's gone he's become some kind of god. Heck, even after Daks first few games last year there were several people wanting to trade Romo and talking trash about immobile he became, how fragile he was and how you could always count on him to play a very good to great game but make a crucial game deciding dumb decision (which he would often do).

All I'm saying is JG isn't the greatest coach but I also think he's been dealt some pretty bad hands over the years and after what he did last year he deserves a pass under these circumstances.

I'm moving on...I hope I'm right but if Garrett gets a full or close to full healthy team next year with Dak playing even average and he doesn't win 10-11 games then I'll gladly eat crow and jump on the fire JG train. I'll still always hold Jerry responsible for all of this mess though.

PS I gave you the like for a well thought out non aggressive post. Thanks.

 

[big dog cowboy]

In six full seasons as head coach Garrett has had 2 winning campaigns.

In six full seasons as head coach Garrett has had 1 losing campaign.

 

[diefree666]

In six full seasons as head coach Garrett has had 1 losing campaign.

thus the true definition of mediocrity.

 

[diefree666]

Garrett is no Belichik and really no coaches are. We also don't have the GOAT QB on our team. Part of the reason NE is so successful is not only BB and Brady but the owner (hate him or not) let's his coach be a coach and GM be a GM. That will never happen here. For the record I like Dak and think hepbe fine, although I am getting a little more nervous, but he wouldn't be able to succeed in that system. Maybe some day but not at this current time.

When Romo was here he made mistakes, a lot of crucial mistakes. Yeah, he won us several games but he also lost us several games. So many people used to bash him but now once he's gone he's become some kind of god. Heck, even after Daks first few games last year there were several people wanting to trade Romo and talking trash about immobile he became, how fragile he was and how you could always count on him to play a very good to great game but make a crucial game deciding dumb decision (which he would often do).

All I'm saying is JG isn't the greatest coach but I also think he's been dealt some pretty bad hands over the years and after what he did last year he deserves a pass under these circumstances.

I'm moving on...I hope I'm right but if Garrett gets a full or close to full healthy team next year with Dak playing even average and he doesn't win 10-11 games then I'll gladly eat crow and jump on the fire JG train. I'll still always hold Jerry responsible for all of this mess though.

PS I gave you the like for a well thought out non aggressive post. Thanks.

7 years. Where as the eagles rebuilt in 2. Other teams in three at most four.

And many of them DID NOT have a franchise QB as he did.

You are happy with mediocrity - fine. 90% are not.

 

[SportsGuru80]

Is water wet? Are Elephants huge? Do Dogs bark? Common answer here YES!

 

[SportsGuru80]

This will show em

I doubt it, but it made me feel a little better LOL!!!

 

[aria]

7 years. Where as the eagles rebuilt in 2. Other teams in three at most four.

And many of them DID NOT have a franchise QB as he did.

You are happy with mediocrity - fine. 90% are not.

And again, Jerry Jones is holding this team back much more than JG. Look what the Eagles added to their roster in the past two years both in the draft an FA then look at us. When their players go down they have the depth or go out and get someone (ie Ajayi). When our players go down we plug in a hobbled LB or a turnstile or rookie mid round secondary players. Thankyou Jerry Jones.

 

[JoeKing]

To the pit of misery!

Dilly! Dilly!

 

[Beast_from_East]

This poll just shows how little the vast majority’s of fans know about football. It’s been a great poll for that.

Don’t like the message, so you attack the messenger?

I guess 1 playoff win in seven years is good according to you, but don’t get pissy because everybody else doesn’t support such mediocrity.

 

[aria]

Don’t like the message, so you attack the messenger?

I guess 1 playoff win in seven years is good according to you, but don’t get pissy because everybody else doesn’t support such mediocrity.

I disagree, most of us have been supporting mediocrity for over 20 years.

 

[Beast_from_East]

Uh yes, you forgot about 8-8, 8-8, and 8-8.

That dude totally omitted the three 8-8 seasons and avoided his 1-2 playoff record like it was ebola.

Cherry picking at its finest......LOL

 

[Rockport]

Don’t like the message, so you attack the messenger?

I guess 1 playoff win in seven years is good according to you, but don’t get pissy because everybody else doesn’t support such mediocrity.

Haha. The only one pissy seems to be you. This poll has been great. Kudos to the OP.