The Carton Show: Rumors of Dak Prescott being traded to the Raiders are floating around

[Chasing6]

It’s not a difficult argument follow.

No one has said Cooper Rush is as good as Dak or is a starting quality QB. Only that Rush was able to consistently win with the same team. That means and/or a number of probable things 1) the team’s talent level is pretty good outside of the QB 2) Rush is better than was thought 3) Rush is very good at being a bus driver and leading a team with enough talent to a winning record. 4) Dak isn’t as significant to its success for the amount they’re paying him 5) The failures in the playoffs (more so the two 49ers games than the GB one although he played a significant role in that with the DEPLETED defense) and big games during the regular season could at least be partially be attributed to him.

What it means in a less probable manner is the defense played “lights out” for five straight games.

Was Dak not consistently winning?

 

[Jarv]

Agree, the chances of losing NFL games a much less likely when you can’t Win QB1 Starting Job

Most reasonable people including 31 other GMs know Cooper Rush win-loss percentage no matter the cost…..isn’t worth the Dak Hate

Why do you have Dak Prescott hate???

 

[HonoluluCowboy]

Dak Haters will NEVER answer the question….Why isn’t the Lockerroom and team captains asking for Cooper Rush over Prescott the way 2016 team wanted Prescott over healthy Romo??

ROFL , We don't have too . Micah's brother and CeeDee's mom already have for us

 

[Chasing6]

Actually it’s a stupid argument to make…..

1) Prescott QB1 is an Elite runnerup MVP player!! - Only Mahomes won the Super Bowl last year….Every other QB failed!!

2) Cooper Rush can’t lead anything. Cooper Rush can’t even lead himself to a starting job and when he starts because of injury, Cooper Rush can’t even pull a Prescott….Arm died after 6 games and the Philly cold made Cooper Rush’s weak arm evident based on average off-season strength and conditioning.

3) If Rush Earned a Starting job he won’t win more than 7 games and probably whither away by game 10.

4) Prescott Earned a Market Value QB contract inline with Franchise QBs…….Facts not Fiction

5) None of the games Cooper Rush Never Started can be attributed to any future Wins…..31 other GMs agree

6) Dak Haters will NEVER answer the question….Why isn’t the Lockerroom and team captains asking for Cooper Rush over Prescott the way 2016 team wanted Prescott over healthy Romo??

I agree with most accept over a healthy Romo.

 

[Qcard]

Way to address strawmen.

Yep blind is blind..I thought numbering the response will assist...

Dak Haters are worthless

 

[Qcard]

ROFL , We don't have too . Micah's brother and CeeDee's mom already have for us

There you have it Dak Haters seal of approval Family and Friends endorsement

No wonder Cooper Rush didn't get signed by 31 other teams.....

 

[SultanOfSix]

Yep blind is blind..I thought numbering the response will assist...

Dak Haters are worthless

Just because you numbered them the same doesn’t mean you answered anything. That’s not how it works.

Dak hater? Why is it with you Dak “lovers” that everyone who doesn’t think he has what it takes to bring a SB to Dallas is a hater? Viewpoints don’t have to fall at the extremes.

 

[TheMarathonContinues]

Just because you numbered them the same doesn’t mean you answered anything. That’s not how it works.

Dak hater? Why is it with you Dak “lovers” that everyone who doesn’t think he has what it takes is a hater? Viewpoints don’t have to fall at the extremes.

I think when it comes to you? You never post anything and the majority of your posts seem to be anti Dak. I’m shocked you have a issue with being called a Dak hater I thought you’d wear the title proud.

 

[SultanOfSix]

I think when it comes to you? You never post anything and the majority of your posts seem to be anti Dak. I’m shocked you have an issue with being called a Dak hater I thought you’d wear the title proud.

Do you even read what someone writes? Or does it just go over your head? Holding a negative opinion of someone’s capabilities or abilities after years of watching him doesn’t mean you’re a “hater”. Learn what nuance means in the English language.

 

[Chasing6]

Do you even read what someone writes? Or does it just go over your head? Holding a negative opinion of someone’s capabilities or abilities after years of watching him doesn’t mean you’re a “hater”. Learn what nuance means in the English language.

Well in fairness your nuanced evaluation is way off from reality.

 

[SultanOfSix]

Well in fairness your nuanced evaluation is way off from reality.

Ok Dak family/friend or someone dependent upon getting his bag. You’ve been here what, one year, if that? Or did you just create another account to support your boy? I’ve been here almost twenty years. I’m almost certain all of the same people who are here defending Dak are those people.

 

[Chasing6]

Ok Dak family/friend or someone dependent upon getting his bag. You’ve been here what one year, if that? Or did you just create another account to support your boy? I’ve been here almost twenty years. I’m almost certain all of the same people who are here defending Dak are those people.

Another far fetched nuance. I am seeing a pattern. I understand now. All of your evaluations are poor.

 

[Chasing6]

Another far fetched nuance. I am seeing a pattern. I understand now. All of your evaluations are poor.

You almost sound like GM Jethro. You think you know something because you been somewhere longer?

 

[SultanOfSix]

Another far fetched nuance. I am seeing a pattern. I understand now. All of your evaluations are poor.

That’s not nuance. That’s a straight in your face actual assertion.

 

[Chasing6]

That’s not nuance. That’s a straight in your face actual assertion.

You are correct. I am asserting your evaluations are poor.

I have never met Dak.
I am not related to Dak.
Dak does not send me money.

 

[SultanOfSix]

You are correct. I am asserting your evaluations are poor.

Yeah because you’re a “Dak-Stan”.The vast majority of your posts here are you excusing his play. Also, me caring about your assessment of my evaluations is like a Sum Cum Laude graduate caring about the last in class.

 

[5Stars]

Ok Dak family/friend or someone dependent upon getting his bag. You’ve been here what, one year, if that? Or did you just create another account to support your boy? I’ve been here almost twenty years. I’m almost certain all of the same people who are here defending Dak are those people.

A lot of us have been around and I remember you and I know you know me. I was gone for four years at music school during the Romo years but I watched all the games. But I have never seen so many/few posters that want Dak to stay, it's really strange.

Was there ever long winding posts about wanting Romo to stay even when he got healthy to play? (i know, he just would have gotten hurt, as they say).

Man, the praise that Dak gets for his on field play is weird. Yes, he is a awesome good man with a new baby, and even if I praise him for that, then turn around and say he sucks as a QB?

Here comes the insults...
(there are posters that have me on ignore, so i'm glad this post does not upset them).

 

[5Stars]

You are correct. I am asserting your evaluations are poor.

I have never met Dak.
I am not related to Dak.
Dak does not send me money.

Would you like to meet Trance?

 

[TheMarathonContinues]

Yeah because you’re a “Dak-Stan”.The vast majority of your posts here are you excusing his play. Also, me caring about your assessment of my evaluations is like a Sum Cum Laude graduate caring about the last in class.

You get upset about being labeled a “Dak hater”’but label him “Dak Stan”…..the hypocrisy….

 

[SultanOfSix]

A lot of us have been around and I remember you and I know you know me. I was gone for four years at music school during the Romo years but I watched all the games. But I have never seen so many/few posters that want Dak to stay, it's really strange.

Was there ever long winding posts about wanting Romo to stay even when he got healthy to play? (i know, he just would have gotten hurt, as they say).

Man, the praise that Dak gets for his on field play is weird. Yes, he is a awesome good man with a new baby, and even if I praise him for that, then turn around and say he sucks as a QB?

Here comes the insults...
(there are posters that have me on ignore, so i'm glad this post does not upset them).

The problem is “Dak-Stans” see even legitimate criticism of Dak as hate. This is because when you get too emotionally involved you lose objectivity, which leads you to question if they have more than a cursory association to a player. If you go back and read what I wrote, I was just clarifying the argument that others made about Rush’s play (it wasn’t even me) and what it emphasized negatively about Dak. They are all valid points and had no “hate” imbued in them.