Despite the small sample I'd take Justin Herbert over Dak today. And I'll do so for one reason. Herbert has shown that he can vertically challenge the field with high level throws. he can simply make throws that Dak cannot make.
Man that looks a lot like the same garbage yall were peddling about Dalton for the last two weeks..
1) Coming into the season Dak and Russ were ranked #1 and #2 in deepball accuracy in the entire league.
2) At the time he went down Dak was #1 or #2 in the league in passes of over 40 yards.. and that was without ever getting the chance to roast our defense.
3) You idiots have spent months telling me that "stats don't matter, just wins" and now you want to dump a guy who has won 60% of his starts in the NFL for a guy who is 1-4? Why? Because you like the way he looks while losing? Is he prettier than Dak? What am I missing?
As they say in my country GTFOH!
Why don't you people just come clean and tell us the real reason you would take just about any QB over Dak.
It can't be his play.. because he was playing top 5 level at his position when he went down..
It can't be his character because the kid is a top notch human being across the board.
It can't be wins and losses because this dude just admitted he would take a guy with a WORSE record over Dak.
What's the real reason? Come on.. we won't tell nobody.. let it out..