Seven;1554156 said:
Why would you be mad at a poster who states his opinion? I find that odd.
C'mon, you've been around long enough to know that sometimes, people get pissed at each other on these boards... I was just telling you that's not the case here...
What I find even more odd is this entire portion of your post. Why would you even include the above statements? You feel the need to not insult me but yet you continue on with it. You can't rob and beat the Pope, then say "sorry 'bout that big guy. ."
I felt called on to make a point I had a hunch you'd find offensive, and was more or less apologizing for it in advance... you weren't being ignorant or anything like that...
However, the claim of Culpepper being a huge upgrade over Harrington is a quantum leap in itself.
I stand by what I said... as we say in sports arguments, Joey Harrington couldn't carry Daunte Culpepper's jock... to me, that's so crystal clear that it merited the borderline insulting comments I made...
Player A has a 98.8 quarterback rating for his career, player B has a 68.1...
Player A has completed 64.2 per cent of his passes for his career, player B has completed 55.2 per cent...
Player A has a 7.7 yards per attempt average for his career, player B has a 5.7 yards per attempt...
Player A has thrown 137 TDs for his career, to 89 ints... player B has thrown 72 TDs to 77 ints...
Which quarterback is the demonstrably superior player??
And before you go to arguing that Culpepper played for better teams, look at their numbers last year, when both had turns leading the same team:
QBR-- Culpepper 77.0, Harrington 68.2...
Completion percentage-- Culpepper 60.4, Harrington 55.2...
Yards per attempt-- Culpepper 6.93, Harrington 5.76...
TDs to ints ratio-- Culpepper 2/3, Harrington 12/15...
Even when they played for the same team, a less than 100 per cent Daunte Culpepper outplayed Joey Harrington...
The numbers don't lie...
It's too bad he wouldn't consider a backup role to Romo. That's all he is.
His numbers dispute that assertion... I'd be real interested to see what he could do with a team if he a) was healthy again, and b) actually had a solid running game to take some of the heat off of him...