What is he projecting?
Turp is obviously a decent returner. Overrated, but still pretty good. I admittedly overrated him last year, but we were hard up for a returner.
Dowdle's fumble doesn't worry me all that much. It worries me, but not much. It's not outrageous to be concerned that Turpin could be prone to fumbles.
I agree. There is zero chance a guy like Turpin can ever make a Pro Bowl
It's a popularity contest. ProBowl isn't really indicative of all that much, especially when it comes to Cowboys players. Cowboys have the most fans, so of course, their players are going to get the most votes.
He's a decent returner. Maybe Turp will be better in McCarthy's offense. The fact he couldn't get on the field much last year in spite of us needing a WR to step up, should tell us something. I'm not saying he sucks as a returner. But it has yet to be seen what he can do against a top-level NFL defense. I'm not writing him off. I still want to see more of what he can do.
My deal is, if all he is going to do is return, and is prone to fumble, there may be a better player to fill his roster spot. If he can contribute to the offense, I'm all good with it. Time will tell. There are still 3 preseason games left.