LACowboysFan1
Well-Known Member
- Messages
- 11,640
- Reaction score
- 7,578
Dude I cannot stand here and let you disrespect Doug Williams like this. Yes his record in Tampa was 33-33.. But did you happen to notice what Tampa's record was in the years before and after him? They were 2-30 the two years before they drafted him.. then went 12-52 in the four years after they refused to sign him. In fact It took the Bucs until 1991 .. almost 10 full seasons to match the 33 wins that Williams led them to. And after having a winning record 3 of the 5 years Williams was their starter and one of those was the 9 game strike year in '82.. They did not have another winning record from 1982, Williams last year until 1997. 15 years!!! The Bucs should have paid him and they would not have had to waste 5 or 6 first round draft picks on QBs trying to replace him. He was the heart and soul of those teams. Not signing him was the biggest mistake in franchise history. When they refused to sign him many of the great players on the team revolted. Leroy Selmon retired rather than have back surgery. Hugh Green and Richard Wood demanded to be traded. So did Jimmie Giles.
I also think your recollection of the Super Bowl win against the Broncos is foggy. Timmy Smith had 5 carries for 9 yards until Williams hit Sanders on that 80 yard bomb to start the second quarter. THAT is what loosened up the Denver defense.. On Washington's next possession after that Smith had 2 carries for 20 yards.. Then on the possession after that he had one carry for a 58 yard TD. Coincidence? I think not.. Williams body was starting to break down by the time he got to the Skins.. he had taken a beating behind a bad o-line in Tampa and then again in the 3 years he spent in the USFL. He could not hold up a whole regular season anymore.. His knees were shot but he could still sling it .. None of his passes in that Super Bowl were "poorly thrown." I'm not sure where you got that from.
Here is the first TD
On whose planet is that "poorly thrown?"
Here is the second TD at the 00:55 mark ..
again perfectly placed over the shoulder is "poorly thrown?"
How about this one to the tight end at the 10:42 mark.
Not a lot of adjusting there either..
I don't know what you have against Doug Williams.. but you could not be more wrong about this take.
Oh yeah.. Plunkett was the full time starter both in 1980 and 1983. I don't know where you get the idea that he was the backup at any point on those teams.
Nothing against Williams, but to say he wasn't average, based on his entire career, is not supported. imo. Just look at the Sanders photo above - tight coverage, right? All Williams did was throw it to the end zone, Sanders just ran under it. Same with another td pass, the receiver had to run yards to his right to get to the ball, that wasn't a well thrown pass.
I have no problem with saying he had a very good SB. That's obvious. But like I said, ONE game doesn't make a player great....