With McCarthy, Trey Lance could be great

[HungryLion]

OMG. You just repeated the same thing that I countered. The fact they they didn’t make a conference championship game or SB was a big disappointment because you had gained the #1 seed playing all year proving that you were a SB capable roster. Just because you don’t make it there doesn’t just negate it. Then playing in the regular season would be pointless and they would just have playoffs for all teams.

And what the teams are in prior or later years have nothing to do with the current year.

How many accounts do you have?

Btw. You do realize Dak was the QB the entire regular season where they earned that #1 seed. Right? Right?

You keep using the fact they were the #1 seed as proof they were a Super Bowl roster. When Dak literally started every single game to win that #1 seed.

 

[WillieBeamen]

Trey right now >>> Dak in 2017

There is no doubt in my mind Trey can go out there and play better than Dak did that season

 

[SultanOfSix]

No. It’s an opinion and a ****** one at that.

At least my opinion is based on you know. The actual results.

You want to argue that a DL with Jack Crawford and Malik Collin’s starting along Tyrone Crawford was just the bees knees then go right ahead.

I said it wasn’t “PURELY opinion” like you claimed. Learn to read.

Your opinion is based on nothing but a claim that they weren’t a SB capable roster because they didn’t get to an NFC championship game or SB which totally arbitrary, because it dismisses everything that occurred during the year.

 

[HungryLion]

Trey right now >>> Dak in 2017

There is no doubt in my mind Trey can go out there and play better than Dak did that season

Maybe. But the entire point is to get BETTER at QB. Not just more of the same.

Personally I would rather draft somebody and start fresh.

 

[HungryLion]

I said it wasn’t “PURELY opinion” like you claimed. Learn to read.

Your opinion is based on nothing but a claim that they weren’t a SB capable roster because they didn’t get to an NFC championship game or SB which totally arbitrary, because it dismisses everything that occurred during the year.

And what’s yours based on? Mines based on how the team actually performed where it counts, the W/L column in the playoffs and their performance in the playoffs.

What’s your based on again. You made a vague referenced to “facts about the game”.

What facts about the game is your position based off of? The only thing you offered so far was that they were the #1 seed. Which is laughable because they earned the #1 seed with Dak starting every game.

So please, share the “facts about the game” as to why it was a Super Bowl roster. The facts that aren’t based on your feels.

 

[SultanOfSix]

And what’s yours based on? Mines based on how the team actually performed where it counts, the W/L column in the playoffs and their performance in the playoffs.

What’s your based on again. You made a vague referenced to “facts about the game”.

What facts about the game is your position based off of? The only thing you offered so far was that they were the #1 seed. Which is laughable because they earned the #1 seed with Dak starting every game.

So please, share the “facts about the game” as to why it was a Super Bowl roster. The facts that aren’t based on your feels.

Hey dummy.

You made a claim that it wasn’t a SB capable team. I said then what does a #1 seed across a sixteen game season prove? That it was pure luck? They just play the games for fun and roll the dice? I also said they had the 5th or 6th ranked defense during the year.

You base it on results that they didn’t get to a SB or a NFC championship game. That doesn’t qualify a team as a SB capable team. That qualifies them as not fulfilling their potential to be one. You just arbitrarily chose such a qualification because you’re using the same Dak-Stan excuse of blaming the defense for the team not being SB capable.

 

[LOBO7]

It's amazing how people see what they want to see.
Lance has a long way to go.
Right now, he's a better runner than he is a passer.
He's not anywhere close to taking Dak's place.

There’s a scenario where he takes over week 8.

 

[WillieBeamen]

Maybe. But the entire point is to get BETTER at QB. Not just more of the same.

Personally I would rather draft somebody and start fresh.

You think Trey peaked??

 

[WillieBeamen]

@HungryLion dont rewrite history to make Dak look better than he was

If we went back to Romo, the 2016 team was our best chance at a Super Bowl since the 90s

 

[HungryLion]

You think Trey peaked??

No but how long you wanna wait to see what his peak is? He is still so raw

 

[HungryLion]

Hey dummy.

You made a claim that it wasn’t a SB capable team. I said then what does a #1 seed across a sixteen game season prove? That it was pure luck? They just play the games for fun and roll the dice? I also said they had the 5th or 6th ranked defense during the year.

You base it on results that they didn’t get to a SB or a NFC championship game. That doesn’t qualify a team as a SB capable team. That qualifies them as not fulfilling their potential to be one. You just arbitrarily chose such a qualification because you’re using the same Dak-Stan excuse of blaming the defense for the team not being SB capable.

Hey buddy, Dak was the QB for every single game to earn that #1 seed. So if that’s your argument, a team earning the #1 seed means it’s Super Bowl caliber, then he was part and parcel of that Super Bowl caliber roster.

So through that lens maybe now you can see how absolutely stupid your argument is.


Maybe you’re right though. I’ll apologize now to the living legends. Jack Crawford, Terrell McLain, Maliek Collins, Tyrone Crawford, morris claiborne, Orlando scandrick, Byron Jones.

The key pieces to that legendary 2016 defense that was held back by that dastardly Dak Prescott.

 

[Chasing6]

Reminds me of Dak's early years..

You should see a Dr. about that.

 

[Chasing6]

Agree, and many QBs who could have benefited from sitting for a year or two just don’t get the time to do that due to money/cap.

It creates the QB supply problem that results in a worse overall product and the league really needs to take a long look at some sort of fix, but Roger is too busy trying to grab money from foreign countries so he can keep his job.

He is sitting on year 5.

 

[Chasing6]

Who did Lance play with in his first 3 NFL seasons?

That's what my post was about, so that's what you're asking me about, right?

I'll answer: Lance had the best supporting cast in the entire NFL, the San Francisco 49ers.

He failed MISERABLY there, and forced a trade last year because he couldn't even earn a BACKUP SPOT.

Thanks for playing!

But he beat our Jimmy G.

 

[Chasing6]

Are we comparing Trey to rookie Dak, or polished Dak?

Yes, let's compare 4 year rookie Trance to Dak's actually rookie year.

 

[Chasing6]

Wait dude....

Dak had a really good team. What has Trey played with up to now?

Come on. You know dang well Dak didn't have to prove himself with nobodies. NOT similar AT ALL!

The Niners has a bunch of nobodies?

 

[5Stars]

Yes, let's compare 4 year rookie Trance to Dak's actually rookie year.

BOLD> Well, guess what?

 

[5Stars]

The Niners has a bunch of nobodies?

Try to make sense someday...nobody.
49'ers suck.

 

[Chasing6]

Just comparing the trajectory
And to make a point, Dak was pedestrian his first few years. Comparable to Trey.

Wait Trance has a trajectory?

Going from 3rd overall to traded for a 4th round pick is a downward trend.

 

[khiladi]

You guys are inflating Dak's impact. He was very inaccurate his first few seasons, he could not get in sync with Dez, or any of the other receivers for that matter, who all seemed to thrive with Romo under center. The success of that team was built on the offensive line, and the running game. He seldom threw picks because he seldom threw past 10 yrds.

They forget how bad Dak was in year 2. He has 3 pick 6s before Linehan had to take the reins away from him and go Zeke heavy. Then Zeke was suspended and Dak was horrible and couldn’t even put up double-digit points against any of the winning teams he played during that stretch and he struggled againsr bums. Then he was awful in the Dak-friendly offense and Dallas had to leverage a bunch of picks to get Amari who saved him. But Dak still sucked against zone. And so on…