Would you like to see Drew Bledsoe back next year?

[jterrell]

Ben Coates, Curtis Martin and terry Glen.

And he made it to the Super Bowl with those guys right?

But Terry Glenn is NOT a hall of famer.
Ben Coates is NOT a Hall of Famer.

 

[iceberg]

Talent around the QB ultimately determines who wins titles.
Peyton Manning is still not a Super Bowl QB.

and who said he was? now, go offer a poll on who people would rather have (if possible) drew or manning, for our qb.

then get out your kleenix and bucket full of excuses.

 

[MichaelWinicki]

Post the damn Dallas stats at QB iceberg then.
Go back 13 years and compare season to season if you like.

You are not making any points because you are offering no comparison at all.
You aren't making any argument you are just making statements with no meaning.

Like a little magic 8ball.

No back to back 80+ QB rating seasons except a 3 year stretch?
ROFLMAO.
He has posted an 80+ 5 times. Only 1 time previous to this year not in that 3 year stratch. That point is meaningless and comedic.

As for Winky ask him how many playoff games Archie Manning had?
Bledsoe was good enough to get to a Super Bowl so he can do it. He obviously doesn't prevent winning. He is also not a guarantee of winning.

He is a 4 time Pro Bowl QB. 4 time!!!
He has a 4-3 playoff record.
He set 10 franchise records in Buffalo in 1997.

Ah JT...

Drew didn't play in Buffalo in 1997.

 

[Jarv]

Talent around the QB ultimately determines who wins titles.
Peyton Manning is still not a Super Bowl QB.

Would you rather have Bledsoe on our team vs Manning ?

 

[iceberg]

Would you rather have Bledsoe on our team vs Manning ?

start a poll - let's see. it's officially the offseason now and time to get silly for a few weeks while we kill playoff time.

 

[MichaelWinicki]

Post the damn Dallas stats at QB iceberg then.
Go back 13 years and compare season to season if you like.

You are not making any points because you are offering no comparison at all.
You aren't making any argument you are just making statements with no meaning.

Like a little magic 8ball.

No back to back 80+ QB rating seasons except a 3 year stretch?
ROFLMAO.
He has posted an 80+ 5 times. Only 1 time previous to this year not in that 3 year stratch. That point is meaningless and comedic.

As for Winky ask him how many playoff games Archie Manning had?
Bledsoe was good enough to get to a Super Bowl so he can do it. He obviously doesn't prevent winning. He is also not a guarantee of winning.

He is a 4 time Pro Bowl QB. 4 time!!!
He has a 4-3 playoff record.
He set 10 franchise records in Buffalo in 1997.

And he's a lifetime .500 QB...

Pardon me while I don't go apeshat over him JT.

 

[iceberg]

but he had OLine problems in dallas last year or he'd be .501!!! can't you see?????

 

[jterrell]

wow - wonder how this will get excused away. : )

In 1994 the Pats leading rusher was Marion Butts.
The leading receiver was Vicnent Brisby.
The kicker was Matt Bahr.

I musta overlooked all those Hall of Famers.

I'll be working on an explanation while you find them for me.


Bruschi has made all of 1 Pro Bowl for his Hall of Fame career.

 

[jterrell]

And he's a lifetime .500 QB...

Pardon me while I don't go apeshat over him JT.

Nobodies asking you to get all excited just don't stupidly the other way with made up criticism.

Bledsoe is a guy who gets Hall of Fame discussion.
Thats just a tad bit better than the crap we have been tossing out at QB.

 

[iceberg]

Nobodies asking you to get all excited just don't stupidly the other way with made up criticism.

Bledsoe is a guy who gets Hall of Fame discussion.
Thats just a tad bit better than the crap we have been tossing out at QB.

yet he's much like manning - NOT a superbowl qb.

no one said he's not better than what we had. not that i've seen. many ARE saying it's not enough and base that off 13 years of history, not 1 year where we've got excuses to cover it.

 

[iceberg]

In 1994 the Pats leading rusher was Marion Butts.
The leading receiver was Vicnent Brisby.
The kicker was Matt Bahr.

I musta overlooked all those Hall of Famers.

I'll be working on an explanation while you find them for me.


Bruschi has made all of 1 Pro Bowl for his Hall of Fame career.

sorry, i'm still digging up all the records he set in buffalo in 97.

 

[gbrittain]

I wonder if Tampa Bay would trade us Chris Simms for Drew Bledsoe straight up?

Chris Simms is having a very Bledsoe kind of year:

61%
2035 yards (10 game starts)
10 TD
7 INT
81.4 Rating

3rd Year in the NFL
Team in playoffs
About a decade younger
More mobile
Upside

 

[jterrell]

It doesn't surprise me one bit. He wouldn't know a pertinent fact about how to judge a QB if it bit him square in the shorts.

Ah, but you do???

Please do enlighten me on which QB we have that is a franchise guy or which QB we need to go get? Hurry up now Bill Walsh I wait with baited breath for the experts response. I want to get the info faxed to Jerry ASAP!

Its always easy to say we need to get better as long as you don't have to like, actually do anything, but flap gums.

 

[Hostile]

Nobodies asking you to get all excited just don't stupidly the other way with made up criticism.

Bledsoe is a guy who gets Hall of Fame discussion.
Thats just a tad bit better than the crap we have been tossing out at QB.

I for one am tired of the comparisons to Vinny, Q, Leaf, Hutch, et al.

Is he better than those guys? Yes, and no one will ever convince me differently.

Is he going to lead us to a Super Bowl win? At this point in his career the safer answer is no he will not.

Should I then be satisified that he is better than those stiffs, or should I have the audacity to hope we will yet improve at QB? Put me down for door #2 Monty.

 

[Hostile]

Ah, but you do???

Please do enlighten me on which QB we have that is a franchise guy or which QB we need to go get? Hurry up now Bill Walsh I wait with baited breath for the experts response. I want to get the info faxed to Jerry ASAP!

Its always easy to say we need to get better as long as you don't have to like, actually do anything, but flap gums.

Are you seriously going to sit there and tell me you give credence to someone who places Bledsoe above Montana, Staubach, and Aikman?

Answer that and I'll answer yours. Without "Bill Walsh" high school insults.

 

[jterrell]

sorry, i'm still digging up all the records he set in buffalo in 97.

You might try 2002 while well there is no where for me to find all that hall of fame talent in 1994.

 

[iceberg]

Ah, but you do???

Please do enlighten me on which QB we have that is a franchise guy or which QB we need to go get? Hurry up now Bill Walsh I wait with baited breath for the experts response. I want to get the info faxed to Jerry ASAP!

Its always easy to say we need to get better as long as you don't have to like, actually do anything, but flap gums.

can i turn on my sarcasm also???? this could be fun and get a lot of threads moved!!! : )

 

[gbrittain]

I for one am tired of the comparisons to Vinny, Q, Leaf, Hutch, et al.

Is he better than those guys? Yes, and no one will ever convince me differently.

Is he going to lead us to a Super Bowl win? At this point in his career the safer answer is no he will not.

Should I then be satisified that he is better than those stiffs, or should I have the audacity to hope we will yet improve at QB? Put me down for door #2 Monty.

Thank You Hos.

If I hear one more time that Drew Bledsoe is the best QB we have had in years, I might lose my mind.

That is not a great accomplishment when VT, QC, CH, and RL have been your QBs.

Time to set our standards a little higher.

 

[iceberg]

You might try 2002 while well there is no where for me to find all that hall of fame talent in 1994.

still busy finding the 10 records he broke in 97.

 

[Zaxor]

And he's a lifetime .500 QB...

Pardon me while I don't go apeshat over him JT.

so now that the season is over I can include this year..

so in his 13 years Bledsoe has now finished last or next to last 9 out of 12 years in the division he was playing in!!! (we did not include the year he sat behind Brady)

that is just horrible