CZ POLL Are you happy with Dak Prescott as the quarterback of the Dallas Cowboys?

[RS12]

2 playoff wins in 8 years.

Yep. In that same time frame Staubach 13 playoff wins two chips. Aikman 12 playoff wins three chips. Those two shined when the lights were bright. Even the much maligned Danny White had six! The monument to mediocrity has.......two.

 

[Beast_from_East]

Mahomes
Burrows
Josh Allen
Herbert
Trevor Lawrence

Hurts
Tua
Goff
Purdy
Lamar Jackson

Matt Stafford

At this point, I'd say Dak is no longer in the top 10. Not sure he's better than Carr, Cousins, or Geno Smith.

Hey, at least the Daniel Jones comps have been squushed!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

If we are basing these ratings on how well a QB will lift the team around him and produce wins, then some of these names might need to be removed.

What exactly has Herbert accomplished? Since he came into the league, he is roughly a .500 QB and his team has the most blown leads in the league during that stretch.

What exactly has Trevor Lawrence accomplished? He has a single playoff victory over the QB I just mentioned, Herbert's Chargers.

What exactly has Josh Allen accomplished? He has never advanced past the divisional round, same as Dak. He also turns the ball over a lot, just like Dak.

Same with Tua and Lamar Jackson, I dont recall either QB ever making it to an AFC championship game, correct? So, they have never been further than Dak either.

Look, I have been one of Dak's biggest critics, check out my many posts calling him out, but if we are going to judge Dak on his inability to make a conference title game or his lack of playoff victories, then we need to hold these other QBs to the same standard. At least half of those QBs on this list have never been further than Dak in the playoffs, so listing them as being better is just a very subjective standard. When Lamar Jackson or Tua or Trevor Lawrence, or Josh Allen, or Justin Herbert get to a conference title game, then we can talk.

 

[Starforever]

Yep. In that same time frame Staubach 13 playoff wins two chips. Aikman 12 playoff wins three chips. Those two shined when the lights were bright. Even the much maligned Danny White had six! The monument to mediocrity has.......two.

What about Romo

 

[RS12]

What about Romo

Another QB that couldnt get it done when the lights were bright.

 

[DallasDW00ds0n]

McCarthys scheme and Dak do not belong together.

MM most likely coached himself into retirement after this years failure

 

[Captain-Crash]

If Mike wins 12 games again this year, he will not be going anywhere. Jerry will get a new OC and let Mike just walk around. Mike has found a home.

 

[TexasHillbilly]

McCarthys scheme and Dak do not belong together.

MM most likely coached himself into retirement after this years failure

This remains to b seen. Still lots of football to b played

 

[RonWashington]

Lets do the same poll after the eagles game in 3 weeks.

Let’s see the Rams leave with a loss .

 

[Gangsta Spanksta]

Let’s see the Rams leave with a loss .

There are a lot of people who will pick the Cowboys to beat the Ram that don't believe in Dak.

 

[RonWashington]

There are a lot of people who will pick the Cowboys to beat the Ram that don't believe in Dak.

I think Dak has to toss some TD’s no turnovers to beat the Rams . This is not the NFL Northeast coming up.

 

[Gangsta Spanksta]

I think Dak has to toss some TD’s no turnovers to beat the Rams . This is not the NFL Northeast coming up.

the 49ers game is the only game so far I voted on here that the Cowboys would lose. I am probably going to pick the cowboys to win over the RAMS. Some of us don't think that Dak is completely useless. He can score some touch down, if the game isn't the big game, although he has had redzone issues this season. I'll pick the Cowboys over the Rams simply because I think Cowboys are the better team overall.

 

[RonWashington]

the 49ers game is the only game so far I voted on here that the Cowboys would lose. I am probably going to pick the cowboys to win over the RAMS. Some of us don't think that Dak is completely useless. He can score some touch down, if the game isn't the big game, although he has had redzone issues this season. I'll pick the Cowboys over the Rams simply because I think Cowboys are the better team overall.

I think they beat the Rams as well

 

[RoboQB]

Lmao!
Roughly the same amount of Yes votes.
Roughly 500 less no votes. Because, why bother?
Can't wait to see more bragging about how the QB
has increased approval from 5% to a "whopping" 23.4%!
"Woo-hoo!"

 

[RonWashington]

This is just primary season . The real election on thumbs up or down for Dak at the Roman coliseum is playoff month Jan . Hopefully Jerry doesn’t “ extend “ before then . See how 23 season plays out Jerry .

 

[SoMizzUnderstood]

No because it seems like he hasn't corrected some of his issues since he became our QB. Also he can't get past the divisional round and he struggles against good to great defenses. I seen other OBs win games against good to great defenses in big and playoff games. He also doesn't do nearly enough to elevate the team around him and the offense. It's like everything has to be great to elite around him to succeed.

He also a QB that needs a QB2 behind him to push him. He lucky Cooper Rush's limitations were exposed in the Philly game last year and Cooper Rush led offense don't score tons of points or there could've really been a QB controversy last year. I really wish Cowboys draft a QB in the top 2 rounds to really light a fire under Dak because it seems Dak doesn't really wanna do what he needs to do to evolve but if u think about it...he just lacks the talent.

Also would like a more consistent intermediate to deep ball passing game with our offense and Dak isn't the QB to really challenge a defense.

 

[GORICO]

Being that Im one of the more positive posters here, I firmly believe that he will overcome the ” set up and release “ issues by year 11. Book it.

Shabazz---you are total crack-up....yeah me2....year 11-15?

 

[GORICO]

All they need to do is sign Dak to an extension and I can quit caring about the Cowboys altogether.

that was so funny

 

[kskboys]

At this point I have CJ Stroud ahead of Dak too.

Absolutely. If his career path continues, he really looks like top 5-8 talent.

 

[kskboys]

If we are basing these ratings on how well a QB will lift the team around him and produce wins, then some of these names might need to be removed.

What exactly has Herbert accomplished? Since he came into the league, he is roughly a .500 QB and his team has the most blown leads in the league during that stretch.

What exactly has Trevor Lawrence accomplished? He has a single playoff victory over the QB I just mentioned, Herbert's Chargers.

What exactly has Josh Allen accomplished? He has never advanced past the divisional round, same as Dak. He also turns the ball over a lot, just like Dak.

Same with Tua and Lamar Jackson, I dont recall either QB ever making it to an AFC championship game, correct? So, they have never been further than Dak either.

Look, I have been one of Dak's biggest critics, check out my many posts calling him out, but if we are going to judge Dak on his inability to make a conference title game or his lack of playoff victories, then we need to hold these other QBs to the same standard. At least half of those QBs on this list have never been further than Dak in the playoffs, so listing them as being better is just a very subjective standard. When Lamar Jackson or Tua or Trevor Lawrence, or Josh Allen, or Justin Herbert get to a conference title game, then we can talk.

Well, we can talk now if you read up about evaluating QBs and understand that team success is only one facet of evaluating.

 

[Gangsta Spanksta]

wow, yeses are only at 76% now.