In reality, Dak has always been Dak. The fact of the matter is this was Dak’s BEST YEAR a a QB, so if you were high on him as a real Dak fan, you should be high on him now. So those QB fan analysts that were “high on him” before but are not sold on him now, are just trying to save face as the excuses for Dak are wearing thin to even many of his most ardent defenders.
The same criticisms about Dak from all his previous years by the critics continued to apply to him now. All his improvement in the skills he was already good at, don’t compensate for the issues that make him just your everyday nothing spectacular QB, whose inability to be a real pocket passer and reading the field as well as anticipating and throwing to WRs was always there, including in his shouting profile as well as his inconsistent and at times, awful pocket presence that has always limited him. In reality, the personnel talent that surrounded him, the OL especially, has masked his weaknesses to a degree since he stepped on the field as a professional QB. If he was drafted in the first round by a scrub franchise, meaning expected to be the savior, he would have arguably lasted around the same time as a Trubisky or Tyron Taylor as a starter period.
This isn’t Dak running a Garrett Coryell offense. This is Dak running an offense tailored to him for six years that was heavily dependent on play-action and spread concepts to make it easier for Dak to see the field, while he had the best OL in football. Even guys like Witten and Jimmy Johnson would say Dak is an early progression QB. Now with guys like Kurt Warner doing videos, you see these type of issues clearly.