It's not emotional. I have actually be quite clear on this for awhile. WillieBeaman and others can back me on this.
I said two months ago if this team gets bounced early, AGAIN, from the playoffs, there is no reason to just keep running this thing back to just get the same results over and over and over. How much evidence do you need? I was clear that if they lost early again, I'd want McCarthy out and that you can't justify extending Dak and handcuffing the franchise to him for 3-4 more years.
It's not emotional. It's simple analysis. This team, under McCarthy and Dak, tend to not show up in big games. I did a quick look and when you look at our peers - the 49ers and Eagles I think most would agree are our NFC peers. The 49ers were 5-3 against playoff teams this year. Philly, even with their massive collapse, were 6-3 against playoff teams. Cowboys? 3-5. If you look at the last 3 years, the Cowboys have a losing record against playoff teams, the 49ers and Eagles have winning records. McCarthy, for all the praising some want to heap on him, has not done anything in terms of postseason success that Garrett hadn't also done. And remember, Jerry brought McCarthy in here to be better than Garrett. But like Garrett, McCarthy has flamed out early in the playoffs for three straight years now.
So blow it up. I'll take a few down years to try to build it back up. The notion a team can't be competitive for awhile isn't based in reality given we have seen a few teams make quick turnarounds. Philly won a SB, tore down an old team, traded away their "franchise" QB, fired their SB winning coach in 2020 after a bad season and two years later, they were back in the SB.