wileedog;2199678 said:
The track record for first round WRs is 50/50 at best. To get a certified elite one for sure is well worth the pick.
If AZ is stupid enough to screw this up it is a no brainer IMO.
This is what most seem to be missing -- just based on recollection, I would have to guess that WR is one of the positions that has the highest rate of high-round busts. So often, highly touted college receivers don't transition well to the NFL, for whatever reason. Detroit obviously knows this all too well, and while it remains to be seen, Washington might be the victims of this in due time because of this year's draft. And vice versa. You see relative unknowns making big names for themselves once they get to the professional level.
Because of this, taking a WR in the first round is an incredibly risky proposition at best. I agree, trading a first rounder for Boldin is a no-brainer. He is fast, he is physical (and built to take a lot of punishment), he has been incredibly productive at this level.
Unfortunately, Philly has a lot to offer. However, not as much as I had originally thought. I thought the whole Shaun Andrews thing was because of contract issues, when it turns out it was depression issues. Doesn't sound like the Eagles have any desire to trade the guy (especially with his organization-friendly contract) and his tradeability might have taken a hit with his depression diagnosis anyways. But their first rounder is likely to be a higher first-rounder than ours, and I think Arizona would project that as well.
So what do we do to sweeten the pot? Give up multiple picks, including a first rounder? Give away a younger player or two, along with a first rounder?
I'd be willing to give...
a first rounder
Roy Williams
But unfortunately, I think the Eagles might be willing to offer a higher first rounder and Lito Sheppard, which would trump our offer above. So we'd have to do even better.