Lance still working on his game

Chasing6

Well-Known Member
Messages
12,482
Reaction score
6,428
Let's not ruin all the progress by throwing him out there too early.

Let's take a look next preseason and then put him back on the shelf. That fruit doesn't ripen until 2025.

The greatest enemy of player development is impatience.
Too early? He only played 10 games in HS.

Started 1 season in college. Has basically not played in 4 years.

He started 1 year. Sat the next due to Covid and entered the draft. Was drafted way to high based on being a great athlete.

He has played 8 games in the last 4 years since his last college start, with an average QBR of 38.0

Please explain what progress you are referring to?
 

JoeKing

Diehard
Messages
36,605
Reaction score
31,911
Throw him out there too early? This his 3rd season. He won’t be playing anyway this season, he’s not the backup. The only way he’ll have any chance of developing is by playing. The longer he’s on the sidelines, the less likely he’ll become a solid NFL QB. If he doesn’t get on the field until 2025 he’ll be stale. The Cowboys may look to trade him by then, because he’s not going to be happy as a backup. He wants another opportunity to be a starter and that won’t likely happen with the Cowboys.
Romo wasn't ready until his 3rd season. Trey Lance isn't better than Dak or Cooper Rush so yeah, It's still too early for Lance.
 

CowboysFaninHouston

CowboysFaninDC
Messages
33,909
Reaction score
19,470
The Cowboys used a 4th round draft pick to get a player they had a 2nd round grade on.

That's a better deal than when they used a 4th round pick to get Dak, whom they had a 4th round grade on.
3 years in grades are irrelevant. Grades are for draftees. 2 years in would you give Purdy a 7th round grade? Or was the grading incorrect
 

KJJ

You Have an Axe to Grind
Messages
61,530
Reaction score
38,880
Romo wasn't ready until his 3rd season. Trey Lance isn't better than Dak or Cooper Rush so yeah, It's still too early for Lance.
If he was worthy of his draft selection he should have been ready by at least year two. The QBs that are drafted high that end up being franchise QBs start showing it early on when given their opportunity. CJ Stroud is a perfect example. Dak was outstanding his rookie year and he was a 4th round pick.
 

EPL0c0

The Funcooker
Messages
7,976
Reaction score
3,697
Trey Lance is 23 years old. Same/similar age as several of the top QBs coming out in the 2024 NFL draft (1 day younger than Penix)

Dallas could potentially go from 2016-2032+ with 2 Starting QBs

I think he'll learn more in 2023 behind/with Dak & Cooper Rush than Love did in 2 seasons behind Rodgers.
 

plasticman

Well-Known Member
Messages
10,451
Reaction score
17,525
Lance is a bum. Niners knew this and moved on as soon as they saw this. It's really saying a lot when the QB friendly system they have can't even make him look good. Like it did for Alex Smith, Jimmy G, Kap and now Purdy. None of those guys are great by any means but SF knows how to build a team and those guys benefit. Lance looked bad even under that system.

SF knows when QBs are done with and they move on. They did it with Kap, Jimmy G and then Lance. They don't care what capital they spent on them. They didn't keep Lance just because they traded draft capital and drafted him high. You see this a lot. First chance they got, found his replacement.

Dallas trading for him was ridiculous and dumb.
The Atlanta Falcons moved on from Bret Favre.

The Tampa Bay Bucs moved on from Steve Young

The San Diego Chargers moved on from Drew Brees

All three of them won Super Bowls with their 2nd team. Two were SB MVP's. Two of them are in the Hall of Fame.

Favre played one game for the Falcons. He was zero for four with two INT's.

There are literally hundreds of NFL stories where a player was released or traded from one team and found great success with another.

I understand that we all love the instant gratification of a generational player but that isn't typically how things work out. Some players have to endure some pretty challenging situations.

I couldn't believe some of the names and insults hurled at young Cowboys players who eventually became impressive contributors in their own right. It just took them a little longer. Some of the "pure garbage" that were mentioned included Cooper Rush, Dalton Schultz, Dorance Armstrong, Terence Steele, Brandon Aubrey and Tyler Biadasz.

The Cowboys are approaching this with a new concept. This is a reset of a QB's career that will be treated differently, the franchise will patiently work with him to eliminate those negative aspects without the pressure of immediate result that typically shorten and end the careers of so many young QB's.
 

Chasing6

Well-Known Member
Messages
12,482
Reaction score
6,428
Romo wasn't ready until his 3rd season. Trey Lance isn't better than Dak or Cooper Rush so yeah, It's still too early for Lance.
Romo played in HS and in College. Started 80+ games. It amazes me how people think you can start 1 season in college and you are ready to play QB in the NFL.
 

plasticman

Well-Known Member
Messages
10,451
Reaction score
17,525
Too early? He only played 10 games in HS.

Started 1 season in college. Has basically not played in 4 years.

He started 1 year. Sat the next due to Covid and entered the draft. Was drafted way to high based on being a great athlete.

He has played 8 games in the last 4 years since his last college start, with an average QBR of 38.0

Please explain what progress you are referring to?
I'm talking about the progress of learning how to be an NFL QB. I'm talking about the progress of learning new skill sets and techniques while playing behind two veterans.

Trey is being developed into an NFL level QB. Theoretically, the more he learns the better he will become. iI is his developmental progress that I'm talking about and not actual game experience.

I agree with what you have pointed out, his actual game inexperience. In fact, it is the very reason for resetting the expectations in the immediate future.

Now, is the progress a reality? This is why I say his most important season will be the 2024 preseason. He doesn't have to be Aaron Rodgers, just show enough that justifies continuing with his development.
 

DuncanIso

Well-Known Member
Messages
11,443
Reaction score
7,275
Too early? He only played 10 games in HS.

Started 1 season in college. Has basically not played in 4 years.

He started 1 year. Sat the next due to Covid and entered the draft. Was drafted way to high based on being a great athlete.

He has played 8 games in the last 4 years since his last college start, with an average QBR of 38.0

Please explain what progress you are referring to?
He moves up very quickly.

This is what phenoms do.

Advance faster than others.
 

DuncanIso

Well-Known Member
Messages
11,443
Reaction score
7,275
I'm talking about the progress of learning how to be an NFL QB. I'm talking about the progress of learning new skill sets and techniques while playing behind two veterans.

Trey is being developed into an NFL level QB. Theoretically, the more he learns the better he will become. iI is his developmental progress that I'm talking about and not actual game experience.

I agree with what you have pointed out, his actual game inexperience. In fact, it is the very reason for resetting the expectations in the immediate future.

Now, is the progress a reality? This is why I say his most important season will be the 2024 preseason. He doesn't have to be Aaron Rodgers, just show enough that justifies continuing with his development.
This is his 3rd season as an NFL QB.

2 with that brainiac 49ers HC.

1 with us?

He’s ready.
 

DuncanIso

Well-Known Member
Messages
11,443
Reaction score
7,275
Trey Lance is 23 years old. Same/similar age as several of the top QBs coming out in the 2024 NFL draft (1 day younger than Penix)

Dallas could potentially go from 2016-2032+ with 2 Starting QBs

I think he'll learn more in 2023 behind/with Dak & Cooper Rush than Love did in 2 seasons behind Rodgers.
Like Dak is All Pro or something? He’s only had 1 Pro Bowl since 2016.

I think Dak can learn from the kid.
 

CowboysFaninHouston

CowboysFaninDC
Messages
33,909
Reaction score
19,470
but Rush has surprised us all too....he is not a bust
wait. what!? rush surprised!/ how? he led the offense to a 22nd ranking in almost every statistical category. the 4-1 record was the defense holding opponents to average of 13 points per game. heck I could play with that defense and come out with 2 wins.
 

CowboysFaninHouston

CowboysFaninDC
Messages
33,909
Reaction score
19,470
Just a 4th is no big deal on a player that went 3rd overall. We're getting a look at Lance at the cost of the pick Dallas used to draft Viliami Fehoku this year. Hard to complain about that.
just a 4th. I get it. but there is NFL tape on him already. and he seems very average. not worthy of his 3rd over all pick. nothing like NFL games to show what you really are.
in the 4th we also drafted Pollard, Fergi, Schultz....so its 50/50. Lance is 50/50 too
 

CowboysFaninHouston

CowboysFaninDC
Messages
33,909
Reaction score
19,470
They like Cooper. He's here through 2024 at least.

Trey is going to be a starter. For Dallas.

we are lucky to have the kid on our team.
Lucky to have Lance? why? what has he ever done in NFL to be awarded such accolades? zero. nada. nothing. he is a bust that we are trying to resurrect. guess how many of these projects have worked in the past.
 

CowboysFaninHouston

CowboysFaninDC
Messages
33,909
Reaction score
19,470
If the Cowboys think he can be a starting quarterback in the NFL Trey Lance and his agent will believe it, too. He’ll expect to be paid accordingly. How much is Dallas willing to pay a guy that never plays?
Cowboys have to make a decision by next year. the cowboys have to decide if he is QB of the future, since his 5th year option is 25M or else they have to let him walk and he is a FA to sign with anyone.
 
Top