I get not liking him....but after watching the piece with Peter King...he's always been into analytics...its how he got his start. He just didn't fully develop it in Green Bay. As I said the other day, Andy Reid had a similar background(multiple Championship games and 1 SB appearance) and now people think he's the biggest stud in KC. You don't know if he reinvented himself, etc.
Nor do I want to find out. Andy Reid was innovative in Philly. He didnt reinvent himself. Philly was just impatient and didnt appreciate the success he brought them. Reids system has made McNabb, Foles, Alex Smith, Wentz into high level QB's. McCarthy's lack of innovation drove him out of town in GB.
We need a guy with authority to lead these men. Marshmallow man McCarthy will just be Jones puppet. He will accept Kellen Moore calling plays. He will accept Jerry hiring his Defensive Coordinators. He will basically be what JG was...... A neutered HC who is in his position to take all of the blame for the failings so Jerry can sit in his luxury box playing tummy sticks with Cris Christy, force his way into the coaches meetings and escape the blame yet take the credit if we do win.
Our issue is well know. Listen to Aikman and everyone who knows anything. The problem is the organizational structure. Nothing about McCarthy changes this problem.