I don't care of his reason I don't care for men who beat on women and that is one thing he did. I'm not painting her as some loving or caring woman but she sure as hell did not beat herself up. For those who choose to stand behind Hardy good for them I tend not to have much respect for a man who beats up women, I'm funny that way. I don't look at a man and say well gosh he can play football therefore what he does on his time is really not important.
i used to always think there was never a situation where hitting a woman made sense. the trouble with absolutes is their inability to be flexible.
once in college, i was at an apartment complex party and having a great time. i was outside with a few others drinking a cold one and some attractive girl comes out and she says some guy is inside threatening her, acting violently and "other" stuff and she asked if she could stand next to me until the guy left. i said "sure!" thinking this could be a good way to win points.
a few minute later a guy i knew from gym came out, saw her, and started to walk away from things to get around here and simply leave. she got in his way, and without word or warning, kicked the holy bat guana out of his nuts, putting him on the ground.
i looked at her and told her she was on her own so she quickly left. when the guy could get up, he said he was kidding around about some things inside that may have gotten out of hand (and people i directly knew told me the same, she was just seriously over-reacting at a party) and he finally got to the point where he told her they needed to just not be sitting close to each other so he got up and went to the kitchen to get a beer. she came outside and the rest, i've said.
the guy in no way deserved to be kicked, certainly not there. she was just freaking out and likely on something (she was i found out later, don't remember what but not just drunk) and causing the problems.
now again, this is like '87. he didn't hit her, didn't threaten to go after her, never talked to her again (and i believe he had to drop a class to get rid of her completely) and so forth - but like i told her, he made no threatening gestures when he came outside and seemed to be going out of his way to get around her and she ran to him and he had no idea what was about to happen.
you can do with that what you will. i've also had friends have their g-friend call police and blame the guy for beating her up and yes, she had bruises that i know the guy didn't put there. so while i appreciate this "never under any circumstances" approach, it's not realistic to think everyone will react the same way and live by the guidelines you set for yourself. to make it a blanket statement of "DON'T DO IT" seems to be more for you than the understanding of the situation.
again, i have no idea what hardy did. i did some research on the girl and it wasn't pretty either, but no one seems to care about that.
only hardy.
so if you're going to say if he were a skin we'd not care that's likely true.
but if hardy weren't a football player, you'd not care either unless you were directly involved.