Roy Williams and Sean Taylor - The Debate Must End

[firehawk350]

OMG! As if you know what Gregg is thinking! That is nothing but an excuse!

Guess what? The Cowboys have been drafting ROOKIES to START! You know why? Because they have brains, and are upstanding citizens...

Gregg probably did'nt start Taylor because he's too stupid to learn the playbook! Why else would you not start this "great talent"?

You RedStinks can come up with the most assinine things...

:dissskin: Good dog....Gibbs...(smart dog, too).

Intelligent conversation, football, humor, life; all these things I would consider giving up if I were you. They just aren't working out for ya hoss. Sorry

 

[firehawk350]

Who was in the Probowl last game? I'll give you two choices;

A. Roy Williams
b. Thug Spitter

Make your choice, troll...

Or we can talk about all-pro, which is what i was referring to...

 

[Chief]

No, i meant immediately, first week. ST actually started 13 games in 04.

My bad.

I was just going by what you had written.

 

[firehawk350]

My bad.

I was just going by what you had written.

No worries dude. I should have been more clear. My fault...

 

[The30YardSlant]

So what's happened since then???

He went to two more pro bowls while Drive By watched on a TV that he likely stole

 

[firehawk350]

He went to two more pro bowls while Drive By watched on a TV that he likely stole

But yet he wasn't all-pro? Why??? Did he decline in skill for some reason???

 

[5Stars]

No, i meant immediately, first week. ST actually started 13 games in 04.

Oh, is that what you mean?

You got caught in a lie...now you are swimming backwards?

Get lost, firefly150! Go troll the Eagles or Giants boards! They need to laugh also...

:dissskin:

 

[firehawk350]

Oh, is that what you mean?

You got caught in a lie...now you are swimming backwards?

Get lost, firefly150! Go troll the Eagles or Giants boards! They need to laugh also...

:dissskin:

Or I'm clarifying. You know, close to the same thing. Like i said, you should really consider applying for natural selection.

 

[5Stars]

He went to two more pro bowls while Drive By watched on a TV that he likely stole

 

[5Stars]

Intelligent conversation, football, humor, life; all these things I would consider giving up if I were you. They just aren't working out for ya hoss. Sorry

It's working out fine for me, boy!

It's just not working out for you...

 

[5Stars]

Or I'm clarifying.

RedStink logic...at it's best!

Break out the Clorine!

 

[The30YardSlant]

But yet he wasn't all-pro? Why??? Did he decline in skill for some reason???

Roy Williams:

1 All-Pro selection
3 Pro Bowl selections

Sean Taylor:

0 All-Pro selections
0 Pro Bowl selections
3 Legal issues since entering the league

 

[Hostile]

But yet he wasn't all-pro? Why??? Did he decline in skill for some reason???

Are you of the opinion All Pro is a birthright once you've earned one?

Also, isn't one still > zero?

 

[superpunk]

According to STATS, Inc., Taylor led all safeties in TD's allowed in 2004. Roy has never come close to that and he's had to do it with the likes of Lynn Scott, Tony Dixon, and Keith Davis playing beside him.

To be frank, I have a bit of a perverse fascination of seeing Taylor and Roy playing in the same defensive backfield because they are such big hitters and Roy makes far less mistakes and plays the run better while Taylor has better range. But, Taylor hasn't even come close to proving that he's as good as Roy at this point in time. Then again, it's only his second year. I don't think anybody is saying he doesn't have the skill and athleticism to be as good or better than Roy, he just isn't at that level yet.

And remember, he didn't start for the Skins early on in his rookie year. So we are not the only ones who think Taylor's play wasn't up to snuff.


Rich.........

The most interesting post in the entire thread - ignored.

 

[5Stars]

The most interesting post in the entire thread - ignored.

Give them RedStinks time to spin...their little brains don't work that fast!

 

[riggo]

According to STATS, Inc., Taylor led all safeties in TD's allowed in 2004.

even though that was his rookie season, thats suprising. do you have a link?

And remember, he didn't start for the Skins early on in his rookie year. So we are not the only ones who think Taylor's play wasn't up to snuff.

its true that williams does not like to start rookies. him not starting says nothing about his play, only his experience.

 

[THEHEREAFTER]

He doesn't play for the darling Cowboys.

Why do you clowns persist with this scorned stepchild stance with us. Embrace your own team, history and identity.

 

[5Stars]

Why do you clowns persist with this scorned stepchild stance with us. Embrace your own team, history and identity.

It's envy of the worst kind! PeePee envy...

That's why they do it...

 

[Hostile]

Why do you clowns persist with this scorned stepchild stance with us. Embrace your own team, history and identity.

These guys need a hug.

 

[TEK2000]

Everyone is forgetting how Shawn Alexander just FROZE waiting for Roy Williams to hit him. The guy just turned his side and waited for impact.

Pinkston pussing out, Coles hit, Shawn Alexander hit and MUCH More are ALL in the video linked in my sig.