Quote me where I stated Rodgers "sucked"? i said he wasn't an overly impressive college QB, I said he was a late first round/early second round talent coming out of college. I said his development from being a QB with poor throwing mechanics to completely changing this up his first few years with the Packers isn't something you can see as a scout.
And you're giving me Romo? Really? Romo also wasn't a very impressive college QB, it was warranted that he was undrafted. He wasn't a day one QB, not even a first or second season QB.
And you're argument now is "Team scouts in the top 10-15" suck. Many QBs that are projected to be top 5-15 picks from your crap sites don't often slip like Rodgers did. It was for good reason.
Point to where you said he was late 1st or early second back in 2005 or where anyone (you think is not a crap site) corroborates. I gave you Ted Thompson as an NFL GM who said he was sure he'd be long by 24 until he really looked at the teams ahead of him. you gave me...what?
You're argument is the tired "NFL teams passed on him that is my proof, that supports my claim he wasnt a great prospect" I dont need to succomb to "Cleveland skipped on him at #3 or TB skipped at #5" to tuck tail on my point. People slip for many reasons, one of those reasons is that many NFL teams are continually stupid. In this draft, 3 RBs were taken in the top 5. in the last 10 years, many have finally come around that you need to pass well vs running well.
Nick Saban’s justificatio
n for taking Brown reflects a lot of this:
In four games against LSU when Saban coached there, Brown carried just 35 times for 184 yards and two touchdowns. Still, Saban liked what he saw — especially a short fourth-quarter run in a close game.
“It’s not one of the plays that are on the highlights, but he ran over about nine guys,” Saban said. “It was only about a 7-yard gain, but I had to say to myself, ‘Man, what a competitor.'”
You are rewriting history in your mind. If not, post some evidence . If not, I dont have much more time to waste arguing.
Still waiting for your analysis of his college tape. Tedford was it.