Will McClay needs to become the team's GM!

[Hawkeye0202]

Here AI definition of an NFL GM........It's unlikely Jerry will give any outsider all the responsibilities listed. But if or when Jerry steps aside McClay will be a great replacement working with Stephen. He has done an excellent job finding talent with the draft and drafted free agents. Now he's the latest target........fans are frustrated and emotions are running high. That can sometimes cloud sound judgment......coz there's nothing wrong with McClay as GM. He is certainly well qualified........



AI Overview
Learn more…Opens in new tab

An NFL general manager (GM) is a team executive who manages the day-to-day operations of a football team:

• Team assembly: The GM is responsible for assembling the team, including recruiting new players, and bringing together coaches and players
  
  
  
• Contracts and schedules: The GM handles contract negotiations with players and coaches, and works on the players' schedules
  
  
  
• Draft prep: The GM is responsible for draft preparation
  
  
  
• Practice squads: The GM is responsible for the team's practice squads
  
  
  
• Team finances: The GM may be responsible for the team's finances, including contract negotiations, vendors, and equipment
  
  
  
• Team spokesperson: The GM may act as the team's spokesperson, explaining the team's choices to the media and fans
  
  
  
• Legal information: The GM must understand any legal information regarding the team and its players and coaches

 

[Polkton31]

In all honesty, it wouldn't matter who the GM was because Jerry would constantly override any decision he made.

 

[Hawkeye0202]

Exactly. He's overrated. Same guy who drafted Taco and Mazi. Also the horrible second round picks.

C'mon man........you put TWO players on the table as failure. How many gems he has found over the years? You are frustrated, I get that but be reasonable.

 

[Cowboyny]

C'mon man........you put TWO players on the table as failure. How many gems he has found over the years? You are frustrated, I get that but be reasonable.

Fans are funny, killing him for 2 out of the last 10. Any team would take an 80% hit rate on their first rounders

 

[cald0d30s0]

Here AI definition of an NFL GM........It's unlikely Jerry will give any outsider all the responsibilities listed. But if or when Jerry steps aside McClay will be a great replacement working with Stephen. He has done an excellent job finding talent with the draft and drafted free agents. Now he's the latest target........fans are frustrated and emotions are running high. That can sometimes cloud sound judgment......coz there's nothing wrong with McClay as GM. He is certainly well qualified........



AI Overview
Learn more…Opens in new tab

An NFL general manager (GM) is a team executive who manages the day-to-day operations of a football team:

• Team assembly: The GM is responsible for assembling the team, including recruiting new players, and bringing together coaches and players
  
  
  
• Contracts and schedules: The GM handles contract negotiations with players and coaches, and works on the players' schedules
  
  
  
• Draft prep: The GM is responsible for draft preparation
  
  
  
• Practice squads: The GM is responsible for the team's practice squads
  
  
  
• Team finances: The GM may be responsible for the team's finances, including contract negotiations, vendors, and equipment
  
  
  
• Team spokesperson: The GM may act as the team's spokesperson, explaining the team's choices to the media and fans
  
  
  
• Legal information: The GM must understand any legal information regarding the team and its players and coaches

I think the LLM forgot about implementing a team culture. But yeah, that would fix the Cowboys.

 

[Joey9775]

I honestly think that's how Jerry drags this out yet another year. Get's beat up all year, hires a yes man coach, and then makes McClay the new GM. Everything is different! But not really. Jerry keeps giving orders to McClay, still in the war room, and still giving radio interviews about how cap strapped they are.

 

[Chasing6]

Will McClay has turned down multiple general manager offers to leave Dallas. He has proved to be an excellent director of scouting, in which the Cowboys have drafted more pro bowl players then any other team over the last decade. Sure, he has had some misses, so so do all scouting departments around the league. Point is, he has a successful track record.

With over 20 years without even a Conference Championship appearance, the Jones Family has failed, without the train robbery deal for Walker, it is debatable they ever win a championship since they bought the team. Will Jerry/Stephen give up the power? Only happens if someone who they respect convinces that the best course of action; Jimmy, Bellicheck, Saban are the type of coaches with clout that can try to convince them, try is the key word. Sad thing is, we may already have a strong GM in the building and he doesn't even have the job in McClay!

I love the idea, but Jerry would just undermine him as well. Who are we fooling.

 

[RonWashington]

I have no problem with GM McClay as long as GM can hire the next HC . And let that HC pick his staff .

 

[RonWashington]

Will McClay said earlier this season that the Cowboys avoided a RB in draft due to Rico Dowdle.

That should tell you everything you need to hear.

When you feed Dowdle and not shuttle him in and out with # 15 or Vaughn I can live with it this year . Pittsburgh 18 rushes plus a TD catch .

Yes 2025 by round 3 need a RB

 

[FVSTONE]

Will McClay has turned down multiple general manager offers to leave Dallas. He has proved to be an excellent director of scouting, in which the Cowboys have drafted more pro bowl players then any other team over the last decade. Sure, he has had some misses, so so do all scouting departments around the league. Point is, he has a successful track record.

With over 20 years without even a Conference Championship appearance, the Jones Family has failed, without the train robbery deal for Walker, it is debatable they ever win a championship since they bought the team. Will Jerry/Stephen give up the power? Only happens if someone who they respect convinces that the best course of action; Jimmy, Bellicheck, Saban are the type of coaches with clout that can try to convince them, try is the key word. Sad thing is, we may already have a strong GM in the building and he doesn't even have the job in McClay!

Will McClay has been given all these props for players that he has help to find and draft. With the said, those same players are fricking SOFT and overrated. All I hear is what a great bunch of players the Cowboys have which is turning out to be a bunch of BS!!!!!!!!!! There are maybe two or three players who deserve props, the rest of them pretty much suck! This is a Cowboy team that is loaded with over hyped, overpaid and less than mediocre when they are compared to other players in the league. This team needs to hit the market, have some billionaire step up, buy the Cowboys and turn over all the football side of the club over to a real GM with knowledge on how to evaluate and draft hardnose FOOTBALL PLAYERS, not the candy ***** that the Cowboys currently have.

 

[Risen Star]

Really the only hope is once Jerry is gone, which could be a while, Stephen steps up and claims that he wanted to hire football people all along but Jerry wouldn’t allow it, and he complied out of respect….then hires consultants to find a GM, then gets completely out of the way.

Of course he fancies himself a “football guy,” and thinks quite highly of himself vs others, but just maybe he doesn’t crave the attention the old man does and isn’t up for the bother or the criticism.

I’d say there’s about a 30% shot of that happening, and please don’t try to shoot it down….it’s all I have left lol. Thanks.

Then why has Stephen acted as the VP of Personnel all these years if he might just be the voice of reason? Wouldn't he know he's a fraud and hurting the team?

That dog don't hunt. He's his Daddy's son. He can't wait to slide over to the GM chair.

 

[quickccc]

Will McClay has turned down multiple general manager offers to leave Dallas. He has proved to be an excellent director of scouting, in which the Cowboys have drafted more pro bowl players then any other team over the last decade. Sure, he has had some misses, so so do all scouting departments around the league. Point is, he has a successful track record.

With over 20 years without even a Conference Championship appearance, the Jones Family has failed, without the train robbery deal for Walker, it is debatable they ever win a championship since they bought the team. Will Jerry/Stephen give up the power? Only happens if someone who they respect convinces that the best course of action; Jimmy, Bellicheck, Saban are the type of coaches with clout that can try to convince them, try is the key word. Sad thing is, we may already have a strong GM in the building and he doesn't even have the job in McClay!

So long as the Jones run the show ..and that includes father and son , . McClay will always take a back sit as executive.

Per cap boy Stephen, we will always have and do the " Money Ball " approach.

- draft players per MCclay
- try to to get late round bargain trades ala Robert Quinn, Gilmore and Brandin Cooks
- occasionally make late rd trades for vets ala John Hankins
- re-sign " core" players (ala Tyler Smith, Bland)

- But there would have to be true commitment to player personnel impact - per not one but 2 new RBs ..an impact No.2 WR
a true, legit OL coach, RB coach, OC and impact HC .

- McCarthy offense is stale, bland, and predictable, it does not evolve, It's utterly Horrid in personnel scheme fit and its not conducive
- and the run game is trash and he doesn't make adjustments, ..i cannot tell you how badly impatient i am in ready to upgrade and
improve upon a new HC, OC and scheme. And i want a Shanahan like attack and scheme ..!!

BTW, Jury still out on Zimmer.

I'd only be interested in bringing back Al Harris, Bones and the TE coach .

 

[Walker]

He will only be micromanaged by Jerry. He needs Jerry to get out of the way completely.

 

[baltcowboy]

Will McClay has turned down multiple general manager offers to leave Dallas. He has proved to be an excellent director of scouting, in which the Cowboys have drafted more pro bowl players then any other team over the last decade. Sure, he has had some misses, so so do all scouting departments around the league. Point is, he has a successful track record.

With over 20 years without even a Conference Championship appearance, the Jones Family has failed, without the train robbery deal for Walker, it is debatable they ever win a championship since they bought the team. Will Jerry/Stephen give up the power? Only happens if someone who they respect convinces that the best course of action; Jimmy, Bellicheck, Saban are the type of coaches with clout that can try to convince them, try is the key word. Sad thing is, we may already have a strong GM in the building and he doesn't even have the job in McClay!

I disagree. Will is a company man. The Joneses need to hire someone outside the family and friends plan.

 

[Parcells4Life]

Here AI definition of an NFL GM........It's unlikely Jerry will give any outsider all the responsibilities listed. But if or when Jerry steps aside McClay will be a great replacement working with Stephen. He has done an excellent job finding talent with the draft and drafted free agents. Now he's the latest target........fans are frustrated and emotions are running high. That can sometimes cloud sound judgment......coz there's nothing wrong with McClay as GM. He is certainly well qualified........



AI Overview
Learn more…Opens in new tab

An NFL general manager (GM) is a team executive who manages the day-to-day operations of a football team:

• Team assembly: The GM is responsible for assembling the team, including recruiting new players, and bringing together coaches and players
  
  
  
• Contracts and schedules: The GM handles contract negotiations with players and coaches, and works on the players' schedules
  
  
  
• Draft prep: The GM is responsible for draft preparation
  
  
  
• Practice squads: The GM is responsible for the team's practice squads
  
  
  
• Team finances: The GM may be responsible for the team's finances, including contract negotiations, vendors, and equipment
  
  
  
• Team spokesperson: The GM may act as the team's spokesperson, explaining the team's choices to the media and fans
  
  
  
• Legal information: The GM must understand any legal information regarding the team and its players and coaches

Does anyone think Jerry actually does many of these? He is 1000% not watching film of Western Kentucky LBs that might get chosen in day 3.

I doubt he can even name guys 40-53 on the main roster and the only one he knows on the practice squad is Dalvin Cook.

Him and Stephen didn’t even do DLaws most recent contract. It was whoever reports to Stephen. They brought up his name when that was going on.

Jerry doesn’t DO these functions the problem is instead of one man overseeing all this, there’s about 8 different departments that do each one. McClay gives the most input on pro and college scouting. And gives recommendations. Then Stephen gets recommendations on the cap from his team of underlings. The only thing Jerry does is go to the owners meetings.

 

[noshame]

Hell, I'll take Elmer Fudd at this point.

 

[Typhus]

I was just mentioning in another thread to @Bobhaze that it would be really cool to see. It’s not like the other Owners don’t get involved in the process either. Let McClay have the checkbook and let’s just find out. Everything pretty much is that way except that Stephen holds the checkbook….

Well you said it all right there, and as long as Jerry holds the checkbook, Jerry will be the GM in name.
McClay will never be given the gold card, he is on a tight chain and collar.

 

[Hawkeye0202]

Fans are funny, killing him for 2 out of the last 10. Any team would take an 80% hit rate on their first rounders

+1

Does anyone think Jerry actually does many of these? He is 1000% not watching film of Western Kentucky LBs that might get chosen in day 3.

I doubt he can even name guys 40-53 on the main roster and the only one he knows on the practice squad is Dalvin Cook.

Him and Stephen didn’t even do DLaws most recent contract. It was whoever reports to Stephen. They brought up his name when that was going on.

Jerry doesn’t DO these functions the problem is instead of one man overseeing all this, there’s about 8 different departments that do each one. McClay gives the most input on pro and college scouting. And gives recommendations. Then Stephen gets recommendations on the cap from his team of underlings. The only thing Jerry does is go to the owners meetings.

^^^^This .........bet Jerry can't tell you the last time he attended and scouted a college game live. It's something most GMs do at least a few times a year. I hate to say it but Jerry and Stephen have become lazy......... don't get the impression they wanna put in the energy and time.

 

[Cowboyny]

So long as the Jones run the show ..and that includes father and son , . McClay will always take a back sit as executive.

Per cap boy Stephen, we will always have and do the " Money Ball " approach.

- draft players per MCclay
- try to to get late round bargain trades ala Robert Quinn, Gilmore and Brandin Cooks
- occasionally make late rd trades for vets ala John Hankins
- re-sign " core" players (ala Tyler Smith, Bland)

- But there would have to be true commitment to player personnel impact - per not one but 2 new RBs ..an impact No.2 WR
a true, legit OL coach, RB coach, OC and impact HC .

- McCarthy offense is stale, bland, and predictable, it does not evolve, It's utterly Horrid in personnel scheme fit and its not conducive
- and the run game is trash and he doesn't make adjustments, ..i cannot tell you how badly impatient i am in ready to upgrade and
improve upon a new HC, OC and scheme. And i want a Shanahan like attack and scheme ..!!

BTW, Jury still out on Zimmer.

I'd only be interested in bringing back Al Harris, Bones and the TE coach .

We all know that this franchise needs to grow with the times and stop thinking they can re-invent the 90's type of team. Both Jerry/Stephen are delusional as they don't think they are the problem, where they vastly overrate their roster. As I have been saying, a coach with clout who they trust, is our only hope to try to convince them for change.

 

[Cowboyny]

I disagree. Will is a company man. The Joneses need to hire someone outside the family and friends plan.

Probably right. Problem is, Jerry doesn't believe he and his son are the issue.