yall still think eli is better then romo?

5Stars · Jan 11, 2009

BIGDen;2570716 said:
Ok, but in my defense I WAS typing on a Blackberry and I was more focused on hitting those little keys rather than creating paragraphs. However, I apologize. Hey, at least I know the difference between "then and than"

I don't...then I must go and than learn the difference at some school.

:

BIGDen · Jan 11, 2009

5Stars;2570735 said:
I don't...then I must go and than learn the difference at some school.

:

No, not you. The title of the thread.

DallasGirl50 · Jan 11, 2009

My answer is the same as it was in the other thread.

Eli has a SB ring.

Tony has nothing. Tony has done nothing with the opportunities he's had with the Cowboys. Every year it's the same ole thing. Mistakes!

Until he can prove he is able to take the next step and guide this team to SOMETHING I'm taking Eli.

cowboyschmps3 · Jan 11, 2009

Yeah Manning Sukt...anytime I Wld Take Romo Over Manning....

Scranton Tiger · Jan 11, 2009

I don't think anyone, even the Romo haters, ever HONESTLY believed Eli was better than Tony. Romo is an easy target playing the most glamorous position on the most glamorous team in all of sports. If he doesn't win the Super Bowl and win the MVP EVERY year, someone will say "he's overrated" or " he sucks". Now, give Eli credit for putting together a really nice post season in 2007. He played really well. However, having said that, he has been average to below average for the rest of his career. He was possitively aweful in the playoffs in 05, 06 and 08. No, only someone who wants to start an argument would say "I'll take Eli over Romo". Me personally, the only QBs I would even consider over Romo are Peyton Manning or Tom Brady. JMO

5Stars · Jan 11, 2009

Scranton Tiger;2570997 said:
I don't think anyone, even the Romo haters, ever HONESTLY believed Eli was better than Tony. Romo is an easy target playing the most glamorous position on the most glamorous team in all of sports. If he doesn't win the Super Bowl and win the MVP EVERY year, someone will say "he's overrated" or " he sucks". Now, give Eli credit for putting together a really nice post season in 2007. He played really well. However, having said that, he has been average to below average for the rest of his career. He was possitively aweful in the playoffs in 05, 06 and 08. No, only someone who wants to start an argument would say "I'll take Eli over Romo". Me personally, the only QBs I would even consider over Romo are Peyton Manning or Tom Brady. JMO

Sweet post....

TwoDeep3 · Jan 11, 2009

Which one has a Super Bowl victory and which one has never won a play-off game?

As it stands that is all that matters and all the rest is jibber-jabber.

5Countem5 · Jan 11, 2009

TwoDeep3;2571007 said:
Which one has a Super Bowl victory and which one has never won a play-off game?

As it stands that is all that matters and all the rest is jibber-jabber.

Eli vs. Marino

One won a SuperBowl and one didn't. Who's the better qb?

windward · Jan 11, 2009

TwoDeep3;2571007 said:
Which one has a Super Bowl victory and which one has never won a play-off game?

As it stands that is all that matters and all the rest is jibber-jabber.

Trent Dilfer>>>> Dan Marino

tomson75 · Jan 11, 2009

TwoDeep3;2571007 said:
Which one has a Super Bowl victory and which one has never won a play-off game?

As it stands that is all that matters and all the rest is jibber-jabber.

..or not.

cmacch · Jan 11, 2009

DallasGirl50;2570937 said:
My answer is the same as it was in the other thread.

Eli has a SB ring.

Tony has nothing. Tony has done nothing with the opportunities he's had with the Cowboys. Every year it's the same ole thing. Mistakes!

Until he can prove he is able to take the next step and guide this team to SOMETHING I'm taking Eli.

You know, my (Giants fan) boyfriend uses this logic all the time. It never fails to piss me off.

Yes, Eli has a ring. So does Brad Johnson. Is Brad Johnson a better QB than Tony Romo? Having a SB ring =/= Great QB

tomson75 · Jan 11, 2009

cmacch;2571026 said:
You know, my (Giants fan) boyfriend uses this logic all the time. It never fails to piss me off.

Dump him! There's you excuse. He's stupid.

CutMeMick · Jan 11, 2009

5Countem5;2571014 said:
Eli vs. Marino

One won a SuperBowl and one didn't. Who's the better qb?

Soooo, Romo = Marino?
Is that your logic?

Simple answer- until Romo wins a playoff game,
then Eli is the better quaterback. I don't care how many
miraculous manuevers he makes.
Win a fricken big game when it matters- period.

You wanna compare equals, how about Marino vs Montana?
NOW, who would you rather have.

Ummmm, I'll take the proven winner, not the stat stuffer.
Give me the winner (Montana), every time.

cmacch · Jan 11, 2009

tomson75;2571038 said:
Dump him! There's you excuse. He's stupid.

:laugh2:

Seems I get that advice a lot around here. I think I'll just stop mentioning him.

WoodysGirl · Jan 11, 2009

cmacch;2571046 said:
:laugh2:

Seems I get that advice a lot around here. I think I'll just stop mentioning him.

don't worry about it. My new friend hates the Cowboys. He's a 49er fan.

We don't discuss football.

tomson75 · Jan 11, 2009

CutMeMick;2571043 said:
Soooo, Romo = Marino?
Is that your logic?

Simple answer- until Romo wins a playoff game,
then Eli is the better quaterback. I don't care how many
miraculous manuevers he makes.
Win a fricken big game when it matters- period.

You wanna compare equals, how about Marino vs Montana?
NOW, who would you rather have.

Ummmm, I'll take the proven winner, not the stat stuffer.
Give me the winner (Montana), every time.

I'm dumbfounded. If logic could die, this post would be its final resting place.

5Stars · Jan 11, 2009

WoodysGirl;2571055 said:
don't worry about it. My new friend hates the Cowboys. He's a 49er fan.

We don't discuss football.

Now you've done it! bbgun is going to be crushed!

(damn women, they will break your heart).

DallasEast · Jan 11, 2009

WoodysGirl;2571055 said:
don't worry about it. My new friend hates the Cowboys. He's a 49er fan.

We don't discuss football.

Careful. He's a Sith in disguise.

Remember. The Force will be with you. Always.

tomson75 · Jan 11, 2009

WoodysGirl;2571055 said:
don't worry about it. My new friend hates the Cowboys. He's a 49er fan.

We don't discuss football.

Dump him!

I think bbgun is available IIRC.

As a matter of fact, I think he's outside your house, staring in your window.

Right

now.

5Countem5 · Jan 11, 2009

CutMeMick;2571043 said:
Soooo, Romo = Marino?
Is that your logic?

Simple answer- until Romo wins a playoff game,
then Eli is the better quaterback. I don't care how many
miraculous manuevers he makes.
Win a fricken big game when it matters- period.

You wanna compare equals, how about Marino vs Montana?
NOW, who would you rather have.

Ummmm, I'll take the proven winner, not the stat stuffer.
Give me the winner (Montana), every time.

Do you read the posts or just make it up as you go?

yall still think eli is better then romo?

Here comes the Sun...

Dr. Freakasaurus

New Member

Well-Known Member

New Member

Here comes the Sun...

Well-Known Member

Benched

NFL Historian

Brain Dead Shill

Member

Brain Dead Shill

Member

Member

U.N.I.T.Y

Brain Dead Shill

Here comes the Sun...

Cowboys 24/7/365

Brain Dead Shill

Benched