The question I have about Dak is pressure. Not the pressure from the D's, the pressure from within. It wasn't long ago that he made that ill-advised comment about wanting to be the GOAT Cowboys QB. That's better kept to himself considering the QB's in our past.
How odd is it that we go from the most polarized QB in the NFL to the most polarized QB in the NFL? Sure doesn't help with the required coverage of the Cowboys but do we think Dak ignores all of that? It is fine to have an "I'll show them" attitude but then he doesn't, he follows in his predecessor's footstep and feeds the fire.
It is totally unfair for us to think he should just blot all of this out because Romo couldn't, they're human beings and the toughest job in all of sports is the DC QB and that has been that way going back to Dom Meredith. The pressure can break a man and just make him want to get away from it.
I do think that Dak is mentally tough but I also think thoughts creep in that he can't keep out. It is my opinion that's the reason he had such a great rookie year is that he wasn't asked to think, just play the position. There was 0 pressure on the 3rd string 4th round QB, just play like he did in college. Rely on his instincts, don't over think it, just react to the situation.
I am on record from the beginning, I think he has problems with consistent accuracy but I think the bigger problem is the self-imposed pressure on him to not make a mistake. When he drops back and surveys the field, I believe one of those thoughts is "don't screw it up" and he can't shut that off. Whether you liked Romo or not, one thing we could agree on, the man was a master at selective amnesia.
If I were his HC, I would be releasing some of the self-imposed restraints on him and get him back to playing instinctive football. That won't help with accuracy issues but I believe that will make him a better overall QB and part of Dak's game involves his legs. Get out where the DC's don't want him, he is not and probably never will be a pocket QB. But that does not mean he cannot be an effective QB with the right pieces around him.