41gy#;2094437 said:
I do respect you, but how can a safety playing deep not have deep coverage responsibility?
You do understand that a safety isn't always playing a deep zone, right? That sometimes he has other responsibilties.
Williams was the last line of defense back there. Glenn was playing the sideline with inside help from Williams.
Glenn has to know when he does and doesn't have help in that coverage.
How can a safety not be responsible for a receiver running right at him or his area?
Moss was never running "right at Roy," nor did Roy have "an area." Roy was responsible for Cooley, not Moss.
There is a reason he was being taken out on third down or passing downs.
Roy was almost NEVER taken out on third downs, and he almost never was taken out in any passing situation.
What about Jeremy Stevens burning him twice in the Seattle playoff game?
Stevens beat Roy once, just like he beat Troy Polamalu in the Super Bowl (on the same play). Stevens' other touchdown was more Bradie James' fault.
What about the "Peter Pan" on Shaun Alexander in the playoff game with the game on the line?
What in the world is a Peter Pan? I've never heard that used in a football forum before.
What about him isolated with Steve Smith in the divisional playoff game, in zone, after Newman passes Smith off to him? That was a coaching mistake. I guess Smith smoking him wasn't his fault, either.
Which play are you talking about? None of Smith's catches in that game come close to matching up with your description.
Go back and look at the T.J. Duckett long run this year at Detroit. Roy was the eighth defender in the box and the last line of defense. He totally misread the play.
On Duckett's run, Roy came up to support on the outside, where the lead blocker was going (and blocked Ellis). Jones ran right up the middle, where Canty completely whiffed on the tackle in the backfield, Ayodele got manhandled and James was way too late shedding his blocker. If Roy came up to support in the middle, where Ayodele and James already were, there would have been nobody to defend the outside.
You can say "Roy misread the play," but he obviously was reading the lead blocker and expected the running back to follow. Whether he was supposed to read the lead blocker or not is the question. What is not debatable is that Canty whiffed on the tackle in the backfield and Ayodele and James played it poorly.
He completely whiffed on a goal-line TD in the same game.
Roy didn't whiff on anything. He was blitzing off the offense's right edge. The TD went behind the left guard. There were four or five defenders lined up in the middle who were supposed to stop the Lions from running up the middle, and they failed.
What about his pitter-patter pursuit and poor angle to the football on the Amonte Toomer TD? His Pete Rose slide was just swell. There is nothing like settling for the triple. He didn't hustle. He could have at least chased the guy. He gave up in a divisional playoff game.
He didn't give up or slide. He got tripped. And what about the two guys who actually were responsible for allowing the catch and missing the tackle? Funny how Roy gets blamed and they don't.
Getting Williams out of deep coverage and Ken Hamlin in deep coverage is a major reason Dallas didn't give up bombs this past year.
Roy played plenty of deep coverage last season and was never burned deep. He allowed one completion thrown more than 20 yards downfield, and that was when he was lined up close to the line of scrimmage and played man-to-man.