If you're stupid enough to make that deal, and can actually make it happen, you bet you've got a deal...
McCoy has a 68.2 completion percentage for his career thus far, McGee has a 59.6 completion percentage... advantage, McCoy...
McCoy has a 161.8 quarterback rating, McGee has a 129.71... advantage, McCoy...
McCoy has 29 TD passes, McGee has 14... big advantage, McCoy...
McCoy has averaged 8.1 yards per attempt, McGee has averaged 7.0...
As for your comments about McGee being "the guy who drove 88 yards to beat him in his house, that's just idiotic... the Aggies racked up 244 yards rushing, just 58 yards passing... McGee completed exactly 7 of 13 passes for the game, for zero TDs... it was the Aggies' defense and their running game that won that game...
The truth is, McCoy was hurt going into the game, he got hurt in the Kansas State game while scoring a TD (his throwing shoulder), and probably shouldn't have been playing... another truth is that McGee is much more dangerous as a runner than he is as a passer, and that does not make for a draft prospect that pro scouts will be drooling over... indeed, he'll probably have to switch positions to make it in the NFL...
He's a poor imitation of Reggie McNeal, and lo and behold, Reggie's a WIDE RECEIVER in the big show... there won't be anybody talking about McCoy changing positions when he gets drafted...
Anybody who thinks that McGee is on the same level as McCoy as a quarterback, or even CLOSE to the same level, should be drug tested immediately...
At the very least, anybody who says he'd take McGee over McCoy proves with that statement that he knows little to nothing about the game of football...