Is it Brock Purdy or the culture?

TheMarathonContinues

Well-Known Member
Messages
83,544
Reaction score
76,380
I said they played 4 games against playoff teams and 1 against the team that just made our QB look like Mr. Irrelevant. I didn't say anything else, you added that. I'm sorry if this bothers you, but I know why it does. Bothers me too.
It doesn't bother me lol. If we lose on Monday it will. But right now i'm just confused. I surely wouldn't be mad over Purdy. I'm more mad they have Kyle Shanahan and we have Kellen Moore lol.
 

TheMarathonContinues

Well-Known Member
Messages
83,544
Reaction score
76,380
So me replying about an "if it was Dak instead of Purdy" comment I am wrong for pointing out Purdy's good play? LOL Okay.
I mean you aren't "wrong".....but you are foul lol.
Correct, so Dak has 1 playoff appearance since his 1 playoff win back in 2018.....so it's even better Jerry & Co. gave a 4-year $160M contract to that kind of results.
Again....context. He literally just signed the contract in 2021 lol. This is the 2022 season lol. You are slick. I'll give you that lol.
 

Scott817

New Member
Messages
10
Reaction score
6
You know Purdy has played well beyond expectations. I thought Cooper Rush played pretty darn good too. Maybe Rush is our Purdy and we just are not playing him ?
 

TheMarathonContinues

Well-Known Member
Messages
83,544
Reaction score
76,380
I think you're buying into the Jones's narrative. Jerry isn't the trade guru many would like to believe.
I'm not. I'm just using common sense. If the Cowboys were willing to take a 5th for him....and I really wanted Cooper? Why wouldn't I trade a 4th? Now allegedly teams offered more than a 5th but didn't want to take on his salary. Now I could sit here and believe that teams wanted to lowball Jerry.......but that doesn't make sense to me. So because I want to lowball Jerry I miss out on a talent that can help my team? I don't buy that.

The narrative I do buy is these teams talk. These owners and GM's all talk. They're all friends. Teams didn't want to trade high compensation for Amari because of the same reason teams don't want to trade high compensation for Carson Wentz.
 

TheMarathonContinues

Well-Known Member
Messages
83,544
Reaction score
76,380
You know Purdy has played well beyond expectations. I thought Cooper Rush played pretty darn good too. Maybe Rush is our Purdy and we just are not playing him ?
Cooper Rush played well for Cooper Rush standards. He has NEVER looked as good as Purdy. And Purdy for sure hasn't looked as bad as Rush in the Philly game.
 

DallasEast

Cowboys 24/7/365
Staff member
Messages
62,045
Reaction score
63,308
CowboysZone ULTIMATE Fan
Jerry would not even hire someone if he felt they could change the culture in Dallas. Jerry is convinced the culture he has created is fine...and anyone that is hired or drafted needs to to adapt to an already established culture.

You hear all the time...."what is the "identity" of a team" all the time. Well the identity of the Cowboys is the 81 year old owner! And he would not have it any other way.
Ageism is a poor qualifier. Robert Kraft is 16 months older than Jerry Jones. Can ageism be used as the determining factor for the Patriots' culture?

When should ageism factor into culture. At 71? At 61? I ask because Jones has been what he is each and every decade.

No. The best teams are a reflection of a roster identifying and performing like the quality head coach who leads them. Solidly-willed team culture is not a fragmented combination of the head coach and a narcissistic "me me me" owner.

Single-minded, focused team identify is demonstrated by a roster playing hard, sound, consistent football that their head coach drills into them. This thread refers to the San Francisco 49ers. Anyone know who owns the 49ers? Answer: it's the York family. "Who?" Exactly.

Anyone watch the 49er/Seahawks game yesterday? If you did, did it seem to you if the 49er well-oiled machine was solely a reflection of Kyle Shanahan? Or did you wonder about a product Shanahan and someone you do not even know about interacting together?

Guys on the field play for Mike McCarthy and Jones. Their level of performance is a direct reflection of who they see leading them. This was not the case under Jimmy Johnson. The roster was too defined initially under Barry Switzer. Bill Parcells worked hard to re-establish the essential head coach/players dynamic. Robotic Jason Garrett failed to construct under Jones' shadow. McCarthy's leadership aura has been stronger than Garrett's but not by much.

This franchise's culture is the definition of double-vision. Plays hard. Plays soft. Focused. Unfocused. It is extremely rare witnessing the team string together four quarters of fundamental football within a single game over the past quarter century. Does the team constantly suffer Jekyll/Hyde Syndrome year-after-year because of deficit head coaching alone? Of is their inconsistent level of play partially indicative of who they actually play for?

A split-identify is not a good foundation for team culture.

/rant
 

USArmyVet

Well-Known Member
Messages
8,708
Reaction score
15,031
Seahawks(x2), Cardinals, Raiders, Commanders? Huh? These are good teams to you? I'm so confused. So the Commanders are good because they "curbstomped" our starters? Huh?
The cumulative record of teams Purdy started against this season: 53-55-1 .486 win % (Purdy record is 7-0) 4 of Purdy's 7 games were against playoff teams

The cumulative record of teams Dak started against this season: 95-105-3 .468 win % (Dak record is 8-4) 5 of Dak's 12 games were against playoff teams

Funny how Dak is celebrated as playing great since his return and helping Dallas win while Purdy is belittled for lesser competition when Dak has in fact faced an even lesser team competition than Purdy.
 

TheMarathonContinues

Well-Known Member
Messages
83,544
Reaction score
76,380
The cumulative record of teams Purdy started against this season: 53-55-1 .486 win % (Purdy record is 7-0) 4 of Purdy's 7 games were against playoff teams

The cumulative record of teams Dak started against this season: 95-105-3 .468 win % (Dak record is 8-4) 5 of Dak's 12 games were against playoff teams

Funny how Dak is celebrated as playing great since his return and helping Dallas win while Purdy is belittled for lesser competition when Dak has in fact faced an even lesser team competition than Purdy.
Who the hell has celebrated Dak's return? The damn defense has sucked since he's returned. What is your point lol? Nobody asked for your Dak stats or anything concerning Dak. We know where you stand on DAk.
 

TheMarathonContinues

Well-Known Member
Messages
83,544
Reaction score
76,380
....and if not for Rush going 4-1 they just may have.
If not for Rush? Rush sucked he didn't do anything. If not for the DEFENSE. The defense and special teams played lights out. Rush kept things afloat and didn't kill them until the Eagles game which he was asked to do more for whatever reason.
 

Hadenough

Well-Known Member
Messages
11,015
Reaction score
13,483
Dallas is so "loaded" with weapons that these same guys who say that predicted us to go 9-8 this offseason lol.
I made a prediction like that. It was because I don't believe in the QB. The team being loaded got them further than I thought. Parsons and that defense were lights out early on.
 

USArmyVet

Well-Known Member
Messages
8,708
Reaction score
15,031
I mean you aren't "wrong".....but you are foul lol.

Again....context. He literally just signed the contract in 2021 lol. This is the 2022 season lol. You are slick. I'll give you that lol.
I am 'foul'???? I will never understand why members that are in the pro-Dak camp always seem to get emotional when someone either criticizes Dak or applauds the play of another QB....I guess that is just an emotional thing.
 

TheMarathonContinues

Well-Known Member
Messages
83,544
Reaction score
76,380
1-5 before the trade for McCaffery
10-1 after the trade for McCaffery
Doesn't matter. I'd never trade for a broken down highest paid RB in the league. And they aren't just 10-1 because of McCaffery. Their defense has gotten better and been lights out. Unless you want to give McCaffery credit for that.
 

PA Cowboy Fan

Well-Known Member
Messages
25,320
Reaction score
51,242
This may be true....but because winning the Super Bowl is the ultimate goal...the architect of the franchise has not stayed the same since 1995.

They have been to multiple NFC Title games and multiple Super Bowls since 1995....I don't need to remind you that we've been to NEITHER since 1995.
:hammer:Absolutely. At least they played in championship games and SBs. That gives them a chance. Much better than what we have accomplished. And if you play in enough of them eventually you'll break through.
 

USArmyVet

Well-Known Member
Messages
8,708
Reaction score
15,031
Who the hell has celebrated Dak's return? The damn defense has sucked since he's returned. What is your point lol? Nobody asked for your Dak stats or anything concerning Dak. We know where you stand on DAk.
Since Dak's return the Dallas defense gave up an average of 22 points/game......which is almost as many INT's that Dak has had this season (15).
 

TheMarathonContinues

Well-Known Member
Messages
83,544
Reaction score
76,380
In Brock Purdy's first 3 games, he threw 93 passes. There were only 16 where he had to get off his first read. 83% were immediately open.

Kyle Shanahan is a hell of an offensive coordinator.
He showed that with Kirk Cousins. I don't know why people fail to give him his due.
 

TheMarathonContinues

Well-Known Member
Messages
83,544
Reaction score
76,380
Since Dak's return the Dallas defense gave up an average of 22 points/game......which is almost as many INT's that Dak has had this season (15).
What have they done the past 5 games? You have those stats? Trying to find them but can't seem to locate them.
 
Top