News: Are the Cowboys a potential spot for Jeremy Maclin

kramskoi said:
Maclin better than Bryant? Just turn in your Cowboys jersey bud...and any other ancillary promotional accoutrements.
Click to expand...
I'm a fan of the team. I'm not required to be a fan of individual players.

Should I also have been a fan of:
Greg Hardy
Rolando McClain
CJ Spillman
Quincy
Ryan Leaf
Dimitrius Underwood
Alonzo Spellman
 
skinsscalper said:
You mean the same quarterbacks that were good enough for a yardage comparison, sport, or did you have some other ones in mind?
Click to expand...
Yep, Sport.

The yardage comparisons were similar despite Maclin having the inferior QB. My yardage comparison is logical considering I'm saying Maclin is good despite an inferior QB.

Your logic is backwards because you're saying Dez is better but concede that Dez had better QBs.
 
xwalker said:
Yep, Sport.

The yardage comparisons were similar despite Maclin having the inferior QB. My yardage comparison is logical considering I'm saying Maclin is good despite an inferior QB.

Your logic is backwards because you're saying Dez is better but concede that Dez had better QBs.
Click to expand...
I'm saying Dez is better because Dez is actually, you know, better. But, by all means, continue with your train of thought. It looks dumber with every post.
 
skinsscalper said:
I'm saying Dez is better because Dez is actually, you know, better. But, by all means, continue with your train of thought. It looks dumber with every post.
Click to expand...
Opinion and logic are 2 different things.

You can post your opinion all day long, but your logic about the QBs and yardage stats was faulty.

Most people in the thread admit that Maclin is a legit #1 WR which you seem to be denying There would likely be little difference if Dez was replaced with Maclin other than less drama and less snaps missed due to dehydration.
 
xwalker said:
Opinion and logic are 2 different things.

You can post your opinion all day long, but your logic about the QBs and yardage stats was faulty.

Most people in the thread admit that Maclin is a legit #1 WR which you seem to be denying There would likely be little difference if Dez was replaced with Maclin other than less drama and less snaps missed due to dehydration.
Click to expand...
I've never denied that Maclin was a number one (nice try on the making **** up front, though). Dez is better. That's not an opinion.

Your problem is you have a deficiency in credibility. You have an axe to grind with Dez (for whatever reason) and you're arguing with a failed logic.

Agenda + flawed logic= FAIL from every imaginable angle.

Hey, Jerry Rice had better QBs than Maclin, too. Should we include Maclin in the GOAT conversation, also, or no because it would be, you know, stupid?
 
skinsscalper said:
I've never denied that Maclin was a number one (nice try on the making **** up front, though). Dez is better. That's not an opinion.

Your problem is you have a deficiency in credibility. You have an axe to grind with Dez (for whatever reason) and you're arguing with a failed logic.

Agenda + flawed logic= FAIL from every imaginable angle.

Hey, Jerry Rice had better QBs than Maclin, too. Should we include Maclin in the GOAT conversation, also, or no because it would be, you know, stupid?
Click to expand...
They are on the same tier.

Top 32 but not top 5.
 
xwalker said:
Receivers.

They are both better than #32 but worse than #5.
Click to expand...

Oh ok. Well I don't disagree. I think Dez is a top 10 receiver. Maclin......not so much. I'm not even sure if he's a #1 in this league. I think he'd be a great #2 though.
 
rocyaice said:
Oh ok. Well I don't disagree. I think Dez is a top 10 receiver. Maclin......not so much. I'm not even sure if he's a #1 in this league. I think he'd be a great #2 though.
Click to expand...

Dez is only a #1 in talent. He does not do the other things that top WRs do for their teams.

They have to scheme around his limitations.

They could not sign a raw but highly talented WR like Terrelle Pryor because the #2 WR in Dallas has to have #1 WR type scheme knowledge to make up for Dez lack of scheme knowledge and sloppy route running
 
xwalker said:
Dez is only a #1 in talent. He does not do the other things that top WRs do for their teams.

They have to scheme around his limitations.

They could not sign a raw but highly talented WR like Terrelle Pryor because the #2 WR in Dallas has to have #1 WR type scheme knowledge to make up for Dez lack of scheme knowledge and sloppy route running
Click to expand...
Absolutely.
 
xwalker said:
Dez is only a #1 in talent. He does not do the other things that top WRs do for their teams.

They have to scheme around his limitations.

They could not sign a raw but highly talented WR like Terrelle Pryor because the #2 WR in Dallas has to have #1 WR type scheme knowledge to make up for Dez lack of scheme knowledge and sloppy route running
Click to expand...


That's what I'm referring to. In talent Dez is a #1 in this league. Maclin at best is a #2. There are a lot of stars in this league who have limitations but are still stars. Because he has limitations that means he's not a #1?
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Staff online

Members online

... and 125 more.
Total: 7,904 (members: 225, guests: 7,679)

Latest posts

Forum statistics

Threads
464,054
Messages
13,786,143
Members
23,771
Latest member
LandryHat
Back
Top